[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Material for the telecon of today
Dear all, please find the material for the telecon of today. Yours, Monica -- =================================== Associate professor of Legal Informatics School of Law Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna C.I.R.S.F.I.D. http://www.cirsfid.unibo.it/ Palazzo Dal Monte Gaudenzi - Via Galliera, 3 I - 40121 BOLOGNA (ITALY) Tel +39 051 277217 Fax +39 051 260782 E-mail monica.palmirani@unibo.it ====================================
Attachment:
LegalRuleML-palmirani2012 -RuleML2012.ppt
Description: MS-Powerpoint presentation
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <!DOCTYPE Document [ <!ENTITY xs "http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema";> <!ENTITY ruleml "http://ruleml.org/";> <!ENTITY dfs "http://ruleml.org/dfs/";> <!ENTITY legalruleml "http://legalruleml.org/legalruleml/";> <!ENTITY dfsont "/ontology/defeasible.owl#"> <!ENTITY lkif "http://legalruleml.example.org/legalOntology/lkif-core/";> <!ENTITY jurisdictions "http://example.org/jurisdictions.owl#";> <!ENTITY authorities "http://example.org/authorities.owl#";> <!ENTITY UScode "http://akomantoso.org/us/codes;us/";> <!ENTITY unibo "http://www.cirsfid.unibo.it/ontology/";> ]> <?xml-model href="../../WP1/schema/nrc_mirror/1.0/relaxng/legalruleml_ordered.rnc" type="application/relax-ng-compact-syntax"?> <RuleML xmlns="http://ruleml.org/spec"; xmlns:dfs="&dfs;" xmlns:xsi="&xs;-instance" xmlns:xs="&xs;" xmlns:lrml="&legalruleml;" xmlns:dc="&dc;" xmlns:dcterms="&dcterms;" xmlns:unibo="&unibo;" xml:base="http://legalruleml.example.org/example/";> <!-- US Code sec. 504 in three different versions, URI are works with t parameters This is a legalruleml-look-like modelling not the official syntax released by the LegalDocML TC --> <Assert> <lrml:metadata xmlns="http://legalruleml.example.org/copyrightUS/";> <lrml:identifications> <lrml:identification id="aut1" iri="&unibo;/person.owl#m.palmirani" as="co-author"/> <lrml:identification id="congress" iri="&unibo;/organization.owl#congress" as="legislator"/> <lrml:identification id="mad" iri="&unibo;/organization.owl#mad" as="cour"/> </lrml:identifications> <lrml:references id="referenceBlock1"> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb1" iri="&UScode;eng@/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar1" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb2" iri="&UScode;eng@/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar2" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb3" iri="&UScode;eng@/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar3" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb1-v1" iri="&UScode;eng@1989-03-01/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar1" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb2-v1" iri="&UScode;eng@1989-03-01/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar2" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb3-v1" iri="&UScode;eng@1989-03-01/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar3" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb1-v2" iri="&UScode;eng@1999-12-09/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar1" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb2-v2" iri="&UScode;eng@1999-12-09/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar2" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> <lrml:reference id="sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb3-v2" iri="&UScode;eng@1999-12-09/main#title17-chp5-sec504-clsc-lst1-pnt2-subpar3" refType="&lkif;#Code"/> </lrml:references> <lrml:events> <!-- events related to the rules included in sec504 and modified over time--> <lrml:event id="e1" value="1976-10-19T01:01:00.0Z"/> <lrml:event id="e2" value="1978-01-01T01:01:00.0Z"/> <lrml:event id="e3" value="1988-10-31T01:01:00.0Z"/> <lrml:event id="e4" value="1989-03-01T01:01:00.0Z"/> <lrml:event id="e5" value="1999-12-09T01:01:00.0Z"/> <lrml:event id="e6" value="2012-08-15T01:01:00.0Z"/> </lrml:events> <lrml:timesInfo> <lrml:times id="t1"> <!-- 250-10,000 --> <lrml:time start="#e1" end="e3" refType="&lkif;#inforce"/> <lrml:time start="#e2" end="e4" refType="&lkif;#efficacy"/> </lrml:times> <lrml:times id="t2"> <!-- 500-20,000 --> <lrml:time start="#e3" end="e5" refType="&lkif;#inforce"/> <lrml:time start="#e4" end="e5" refType="&lkif;#efficacy"/> </lrml:times> <lrml:times id="t3"> <!-- 750-30,000--> <lrml:time start="#e5" refType="&lkif;#efficacy"/> <lrml:time start="#e5" refType="&lkif;#efficacy"/> </lrml:times> <!-- time of the case-law --> </lrml:timesInfo> <lrml:ruleInfo id="ruleInfo1" appliesTo="#rule1"> <lrml:sources id="sourceBlock1"> <lrml:source element="#rule1-atom1" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt1-sb1"/> <lrml:source element="#rule1-atom2" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb2"/> <lrml:source element="#rule1-atom3" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb3"/> </lrml:sources> <lrml:strength iri="&dfsont;defeasible"/> <lrml:jurisdiction iri="&jurisdictions;us"/> <lrml:author idRef="#aut1"/> <lrml:times idRef="#t1"/> <lrml:creationDateTime idRef="#e6"/> <lrml:authority idRef="#congress"/> </lrml:ruleInfo> <lrml:ruleInfo id="ruleInfo2" appliesTo="#rule2"> <lrml:sources id="sourceBlock2"> <lrml:source element="#rule2-atom1" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt1-sb1-v1"/> <lrml:source element="#rule2-atom2" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb2-v1"/> <lrml:source element="#rule2-atom3" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb3-v1"/> </lrml:sources> <lrml:strength iri="&dfsont;defeasible"/> <lrml:jurisdiction iri="&jurisdictions;us"/> <lrml:author idRef="#aut1"/> <lrml:times idRef="#t2"/> <lrml:creationDateTime idRef="#e6"/> <lrml:authority idRef="#congress"/> </lrml:ruleInfo> <lrml:ruleInfo id="ruleInfo3" appliesTo="#rule3"> <lrml:sources id="sourceBlock3"> <lrml:source element="#rule3-atom1" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt1-sb1-v2"/> <lrml:source element="#rule3-atom2" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb2-v2"/> <lrml:source element="#rule3-atom3" idRef="#sec504-clsc-pnt2-sb3-v2"/> </lrml:sources> <lrml:strength iri="&dfsont;defeater"/> <lrml:jurisdiction iri="&jurisdictions;us"/> <lrml:author idRef="#aut1"/> <lrml:times idRef="#t3"/> <lrml:creationDateTime idRef="#e6"/> <lrml:authority idRef="#congress"/> </lrml:ruleInfo> </lrml:metadata> <Rulebase node="#rulebase1" mapClosure="universal"> <!-- rules from the version 1 --> <Implies id="rule1" timesBlock="#t1"> <then> <Atom id="rule1-atom1"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#payFee">pay a fee</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#infranger">X</Var> <Var type="&lkif;#fee">not less than $250</Var> <Var type="&lkif;#fee">not more than $10,000</Var> </Atom> </then> <if> <And> <Atom id="rule1-atom2"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#Infringement">infranges copyright</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#infranger">X</Var> </Atom> <Atom id="rule1-atom3"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#electStatutoryDamages">elect an award of statutory damages</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#copyrightOwner">Y</Var> </Atom> </And> </if> </Implies> <!-- rules derived from the version 2 --> <Implies id="rule2" timesBlock="#t2"> <then> <Atom id="rule2-atom1"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#payFee">pay a fee</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#infranger">X</Var> <Var type="&lkif;#fee">not less than $500</Var> <Var type="&lkif;#fee">not more than $20,000</Var> </Atom> </then> <if> <And> <Atom id="rule2-atom2"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#Infringement">infranges copyright</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#infranger">X</Var> </Atom> <Atom id="rule2-atom3"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#electStatutoryDamages">elect an award of statutory damages</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#copyrightOwner">Y</Var> </Atom> </And> </if> </Implies> <!-- rules derived from the version 3 --> <Implies id="rule3" timesBlock="#t3"> <then> <Atom id="rule3-atom1"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#payFee">pay a fee</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#infranger">X</Var> <Var type="&lkif;#fee">not less than $750</Var> <Var type="&lkif;#fee">not more than $30,000</Var> </Atom> </then> <if> <And> <Atom id="rule3-atom2"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#Infringement">infranges copyright</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#infranger">X</Var> </Atom> <Atom id="rule3-atom3"> <Rel iri="&lkif;#electStatutoryDamages">elect an award of statutory damages</Rel> <Var type="&lkif;#copyrightOwner">Y</Var> </Atom> </And> </if> </Implies> </Rulebase> </Assert> </RuleML>
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]