OASIS Management Protocol Technical Committee (MPTC)
Meeting Minutes

Logistics
Roll-call
Other Business
Business In Order
Action Items & Motions
References


Logistics

Meeting Date

09/19/2002

Meeting Time

9:00 pm PDT

Location

Face-to-Face: Cisco Building 21, San Jose

Dial-in Number: To be added

International: To be added
Conference ID:  To be added

Duration

9:00 AM to 2:00 PM

Chair

Winston Bumpus

Recording Secretary

Hedy Alban

Agenda

As published [1]

Roll-call

 

 

 

Member (before Sept 4)

4-Sep

9/18/2002 (F2F)

9/19/2002 (F2F)

Alan Davies

AD

SeeBeyond

Y

N

Regrets

Regrets

Anand Akela

AA

HP

Y

N

N

N

Andrea Westerinen

AW

Cisco

Y

Y

Y

N

Andreas Maier

AM

IBM

Y

Y

Y

Y

Aravinda Gollapudi

AG

Verisign

Y

N

N

N

Darran Rolls 

DR

Waveset

Y

N

N

N

Dennis Ho

DH

Iona

Y

N

N

N

Dick Spellman

DS

Sun Microsystems Inc.

Y

N

Y

Y

Ellen Stokes

ES

IBM

Y

N

N

N

Fred Carter

FC

 

Y

Y

Y

Y

Gil Kirkpatrick

GK

NetPro

Y

Y

N

N

Guru Bhat

GB

Sun Microsystems Inc.

Y

N

N

Regrets

Heather Kreger

HK

IBM

Y

Y

Y

Y

Hedy Alban

HED

Max Shevet Consulting

Y

Y

Y

Y

Homayoun Pourheidari

HP

HP

Y

Y

Y

Y

Jim Willits

JW

HP

Y

Y

Y

Y

Julie Schott

JS

Cisco

Y

Y

Y

Y

Ken Crozier

KC

Cisco

Y

Y

Y

Y

Karl Schopmeyer

KS2

Independent

Y

Y

Y

Y

Krishna Sankar

KS1

Cisco

Y

Y

N

N

Michael Thatcher

MT

Microsoft

Y

Y

Y

N

Robert Baafi

RB

Iona

Y

N

N

N

Sekhar Saukkai

SS

Corporate Oxygen Inc.

Y

N

N

Y

Srinivas Vadhri

SV

CommerceOne

Y

N

N

N

Veena Subrahmanyam

VS

HP

Y

Y

Y

Y

Winston Bumpus

WB

Novell

Y

Y

Y

Y

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

New Members

 

 

 

 

 

 

Kevin Brinkley

KB

Intel

1/3

N

N

N

Jim Davis

JD

Sun

2/3

N

N

N

Bart Whitely

BW

Caldera International

1/3

N

N

N

George Ariola

GA

Web Serv Mgmt Co.

N

N

Y

Y

George Erricson

GE

EMC

1/3

N

N

N

Richard Nikula

RN

BMC

N

Y

Y

Y

Ravi Fernando

RS

HP

N

N

Y

N

Igor Sedukhin

IS

 

N

N

N

N

Bill Dunigan

BD

Cyclone Commerce

N

N

N

N

Jeff Boulin

 

WebMethods

N

N

Y

Y

Yoshimasa Masuoka

YM

Hitachi

N

N

Y

Y

Takaki Kuroda

TK

Hitachi

N

N

Y

Y

 

Other Business

WB

None

 

Business In Order

 

CIM Operations

 

Karl reviewed the structure and characteristics of CIM operations. All operations have a set of control parameters and operate against class and qualifier. These operations are the only door into CIMOM. Interesting limitation in implementation: CIMOM returns only instance information but not class information. The query language will be completed in six to eight weeks. The CIM Query Language (CQL) will reconcile some differences between current SQL versions. Currently there is no standard interface between the CIM server and the CIM providers; each vendor implements its own interface.

 

Comparison of Operations

 

The group built a table comparing the operations that are available in CIM, OMI, and JMX. SNMP and CMIP will be added for next week.

 

 

Discussion of Requirements

 

Further discussion and prioritization of requirements

 

Liaisons

 

Liaisons were discussed and assigned as follows:

 

Organization
Liaison

DMTF

Winston, Andrea

W3C

Heather, Andrea

TOG

Karl (EMF), Winston (DIF=directory), Andrea (mobile)

SNIA

Yoshi, Julie (sys/dev)

IETF Config

Ken

WS-I

To be assigned

TMF

To come through the DMTF

 

Deliverables

 

What

Who

When

Ops comparison grid

Hedy

Sept 25

Requirement definitions

Karl

Sept 25 and ongoing

Use Cases Template

Karl

Sept 25

Use Cases

TBD

Oct 15

Architectural Proposals

TBD

Nov 1

Specification outline

TBD

Nov 14 (F2F)

Drafts of each section

TBD

Dec 15

Preliminary Spec

TBD

Jan 30

Final Spec

TBD

TBD

 

 

 

 

Face-to-Face

 

Date: November 12-14, Tues-Thursday

 

Discuss architectural proposals: message exchange patterns, architectural reference for the environments, hardware

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

5

Motion to adjourn

 

Meeting adjourned at 2:15 PM PDT. Next meeting will be a teleconference Wed, September 25, 10:00 AM PDT.

Action Items & Motions

 

Owner

Action Item/Motion

 

Hedy

Add SNMP and CMIP to the operations table. Be responsible for the grid.

 

Karl

Requirement definition

 

Karl

Use case template

 

Dick

Gather operations requirements from JMX

 

All

See above section on deliverables

 

Winston

Assign responsibility for F2F hosting

 

 

Motions

 

 

 

 

References

[1] published agenda URL