OASIS ODF 1.0 + Errata 01 != ISO/IEC 26300 + Errata 01

["MURATA Makoto (FAMILY Given)" <eb2m-mrt@asahi-net.or.jp>]

Folks,

In my understanding, ISO/IEC 26300 is not identical to the 
OASIS standard ODF 1.0.  Rather, it is identical to 
OASIS ODF 1.0 (Second Edition), which is still a committee 
specification.

(A) OASIS ODF 1.0 standard,

is different from

(B) ISO/IEC 26300 = OASIS ODF 1.0 (Second Edition)


The differences between (A) and (B) are summarized in E.3 of 
the committee specification.  These differences are not minor.
In particular, (A) still uses URIs, while (B) use IRIs.

The draft errata does not incorporate the changes made 
in the committee specification.  Thus, 

(A') OASIS ODF 1.0 standard + Errata 01

is different from 

(B) ISO/IEC 26300

or 

(B') ISO/IEC 26300 + Errata 01

I would argue that the errata should incorporate the changes made 
in the committee specification so that (A') becomes identical to (B').

Cheers,

-- 
MURATA Makoto (FAMILY Given) <EB2M-MRT@asahi-net.or.jp>

> - The usage of key words for "shall", "may", etc. conforms now to
>   Annex H of the ISO directives.
> 
> - Various ambiguous references were replaced with explicit references
>   to chapter and section numbers.
> 
> - Various spelling and grammatical errors were corrected.
> 
> - All occurrences of "unicode" and "UNICODE" were replaced with the
>   bibliographic reference "[UNICODE]". A bibliographic entry for
>   Unicode was added to appendix B.
> 
> - All occurrences of the term URI, with the exception of one in
>   appendix E.1, were replaced with the term IRI, because the W3C Schema
>   "anyURI" datatype that is used in the OpenDocument schema actually
>   takes IRIs rather than URIs. References to [RFC2396]) were replaced
>   with references to [RFC3987]. In appendix B, the bibliographic entry
>   for RFC2396 was replaced with one for RFC3987.
> 
> - A reference to the RELAX NG DTD Compatibility specification was
>   added to the second paragraph of section 1.4. A bibliography entry for
>   the RELAX NG DTD Compatibility specification was added to appendix B.
> 
> - References to [RFC2045] were added to some usages of the term 
>   "BASE64", and occurrences of "base64" were corrected to "BASE64".
>   A bibliography entry for RFC2045 has been added to appendix B.
> 
> - The description of the draw:z-index attribute in section 9.2.5 was
>   corrected.
> 
> - The references to the W3C CSS3 Text Module were clarified. In
>   appendix B, the URL "http://www.w3.org/TR/2003/CR-css3-text-20030514"; 
>   was added to the bibliographic entry for CSS3Text.
> 
> - In appendix B, the bibliographic entry for [RNG] now references to
>   the ISO Relax-NG specification document rather than the OASIS Relax-NG
>   specification document.
> 
> - In appendix B, the bibliographic entry for ZIP was updated.
> 
> - The contributor list was moved from the title page into an appendix.