[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Summary 2010-03-02 - OpenFormula
Summary 2010-03-02 - OpenFormula (As always, please reply-all with corrections.) Attendees: David A. Wheeler Eric Patterson Patrick Durusau Eike Rathke Andreas Guelzow Dennis Hamilton Michael Brauer Rob Weir In this teleconference: * We noted that Committee Draft 1 voting is nearly done (it's currently passing with 16 votes for, 0 against, out of 18). * We agreed on a new "NEEDS-DISCUSSION" marking in titles for JIRA comments where there is disagreement or the assignee needs help. * We discussed and assigned all unassigned comments needed for CD2. Discussion: ============ TOPIC: Voting on the CD. http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/office/ballot.php?id=1841 We have 16 votes out of 18 possible, all are currently voting yes. Andreas: "Some things were misplaced" - namely a graphics chart (histogram) by the process. ("Page 192"). It's in section 5.18.51 NEGBINOMDIST. Wheeler: The chart was probably put into a hidden section, and automatically removed by the document process when the CD was created. Patrick: It's now on page 194 - at 5.18.51 - it's a chart... it's not that it's misssing, it's in the wrong place. Eric: Other graphic object got put in the wrong place too. Wheeler: We should create a JIRA comment to check the graphic objects. Patrick: I'll pick that up.. just create a comment. Some sort of flow problem. Rob: There's no allowance for production errors in CDs, so can't do that. Eric: This will be in the CD - do we want to redo? Wheeler: This isn't worth a revote. Eric: We all agree. TOPIC: Are there open issues that need discussion? Eric: I'd like to bring up procedure for remaining issues. Rob: If someone has a concern about a proposal, raise it to the list. Wheeler: If there's a disagreement, comment on the JIRA comment. Eric: So how do we identify the "JIRA comments being disagreed on"? Rob: If I create a resolution, I comment and mark it as "resolved", that puts it into the queue for adding to the document. If someone adds a comment that disagrees, the editor knows not to do it. Then the it's the commenter's problem to raise it or work out a resolution. Eike: Could create keywords to filter. PROPOSE-DISCUSS isn't quite right. Eric: What text do I put in? Wheeler: If you disagree with someone else's proposal, put in JIRA your objections and the phrase "NEEDS-DISCUSSION" at the beginning of the title. Then we can find them. Once done, edit the JIRA comment to remove "NEEDS-DISCUSSION" from the title. Similarly, if you need help, put in NEEDS-DISCUSSION. Eike: The problem is that you can't remove "Resolved" status in JIRA. Rob: OASIS doesn't give us the right to adjust the process. Rob: You can filter on titles and we can edit the titles. TOPIC: Unassigned CD2 issues OFFICE-2565 - Had a discussion on whether or not this text is necessary. The current text isn't right; something like "honor" (instead of "evaluate") might work. Rob Weir will pick them. Eric: This is really a hosting issue. Rob: Does an evaluator need to give a defined result? Wheeler: There are default values for these settings, so if they're not given, then you still have a value. OFFICE-2566 - Rob Weir will pick this up. OFFICE-2451 - Dennis will pick up. It's actually already resolved. TOPIC: Trial spreadsheets. Dennis: I uploaded trial spreadsheets to try out exact integers, etc., to help figure out "edges" of numerical calculation. We can assess for this, without judging them. This is "NumCheck .10". Wheeler: I'd rather not spend too much time as a group on this. Dennis: Doing this so I can experimentally verify proposals on types. Wheeler: There are already some spreadsheets that store fractions as fractions (e.g., 1/3); we don't want to forbid that. --- David A. Wheeler
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]