spec and xsd issues for Aug 16th con call...

[Gary P Cole <Gary.P.Cole@Sun.COM>]

Draft 27 closes almost all XSD issues.
Recent emails resolve almost all spec issues.
Some work remains to specify agreed behavior.
|1-5 CLOSED.

6. Update "Security and privacy considerations".
20050215 - Darran says that we should update this.  Wants a volunteer.
20050222 - Hal Lockhart volunteered to update this. Keep this in the spec.
20050329 - Hal thinks he can do this during this week.
20050607 - Hal thinks he can do this next day or two.
20050621 - Hal will send this by Thursday, 6/23.

7. Appendix I (throughout): Document references need validation and update.
20050329 - Raj volunteered during the con-call to do this.
20050510 - Hal: Beware normative references to non-std docs.
20050621 - Raj will send this by Thursday, 6/23.

8. Appendix L: Glossary.  Definitions need review and update.
20050222 - Point to a separate document for Glossary.
20050329 - Raj volunteered during the con-call to do this.
20050621 - Raj will do this by Thursday, 6/23.

|9-44 CLOSED.

45. (3.5.4.1.3) Modifying capability data may require capability-specific mechanism.
20050614 - Modifying a subset of capabilityData may require capability-specific mechanism.
20050615 - Each item should be wrapped in a separate <capabilityData> element.
20050620 - (d10) Wrapped each <reference> in a separate <capabilityData> element.
20050621 - Agreed during con-call to discuss this on the LIST.
20050811 - Sent email: "Spec issue 45..." (no replace, no wildcard-delete).
20050812 - JeffB says 1) cap-spec.  2) references a la LDAP attributes.
20050812 - AGREE. JeffB sent examples.  Basically, key=typeOfReference+toPsoID.
20050815 - Slight PROBLEM: ReferenceType requires <toPsoID>.
20050815 - AGREE. Specify that ReferenceType requires <toPsoID>; optional in XSD.
 
|46-57 CLOSED.

58. Provider may need to know requestor's profile.
20050513 - Sent email: "Provider may need to know requestor's profile".
20050513 - Jeff Bohren agreed (in a reply to the list).
20050608 - Reminded Jeff Bohren (in another email) that we forgot about this.
20050614 - DEFER past COMMITTEE DRAFT.  Jeff Bohren wants time to think about it.
20050812 - Sent email to list: "Spec issue #58..."
           (Jeff) add profile attr to ListTargetsRequestType and TargetType.
           (Gary) if profile specified, response contains only suitable targets.
20050815 - AGREE.  Draft 27 adds profile attribute(s) and ErrorCode.

|59-61 CLOSED.

62.  SearchRequestType#query should be optional. Omitted means "all".

63.  deleteResponse element is of type ResponseType (not DeleteResponseType).

64.  (Examples) "path" must precede "namespaceURI" in any <select> element.

65.  XSD 26: SearchQueryType#basePsoID minOccurs=0.

66.  (=XSD#119) LookupResponse contains at most one <pso>.  Clarify text.
20050815 - (d12) Also updated XSD snippets and Appendix A.

67.  Line 2044 "Batch Capability" should say "Bulk Capability".

68.  Can modify add/replace/delete an XML *attribute* (or only an element)?
     Jeff Bohren review comments on examples say only an XML *element*.

69.  Async Capability needs Resource Considerations (like those in Search).

|70.  Discuss ErrorMessages after Status and Error.
|20050813 - Added section entitled "ErrorMessage (normative)".

|71.  Add SPMLv2-UPDATES to "Namespaces".
|20050815 - (d12). FIXED in Draft 12.

|72.  Add SPMLv2-SUSPEND and SPMLv2-UPDATES to "References".
|20050815 - (d12). FIXED in Draft 12.

|73.  Mention Updates Capability at the top of "Operations" section.
|20050815 - (d12). FIXED in Draft 12.

|74.  Replace references to "execution" attribute with "executionMode".
|20050815 - (d12). FIXED in Draft 12.

75.  Provider must honor any <psoID> supplied in <addRequest>.
20050815 - (d12) FIXED. Reworked addRequest and addResponse sections to discuss.
20050815 - XSD 27 adds ErrorCode#invalidIdentifier and #alreadyExists.

76.  Discuss maxSelect attribute of UpdatesRequestType.

77.  Document closeIterator operation of UpdatesCapability.
(1-93 CLOSED.)

|94. Add "profile" to <listTargetsRequest> and to each <target>.
|20050513 - AGREED on list: "Provider may need to know requestor's profile."
|20050614 - DEFER until after COMMITTEE DRAFT.  Jeff Bohren wants time to think about it.
|20050809 - In con-call, Jeff Bohren says now to resolve this week.
|20050812 - Repeated suggestion in email to list: "Spec issue #58...)
|20050816 - Draft 27 adds ErrorCode#unsupportedProfile.
|20050816 - Draft 27 adds #profile to ListTargetsRequestType and TargetType.

(95-113 CLOSED.)

|114. (see XSD issue #107) Remove updates:ResultsIteratorType#count and #totalCount.
|20050816 - Draft 27.

115. (Default cardinality) UpdatesResponseType#iterator minOccurs=1, maxOccurs=1 
20050816 - Draft 27.
20050816 - UpdatesResponseType#iterator should be minOccurs=0.

|116. Add 'maxSelect' attribute to UpdatesRequestType (a la SearchRequestType)?
|20050816 - Draft 27.

|117. Add 'closeIterator' operation to Updates Capability?
|20050816 - Draft 27.

|118. SearchQueryType contains 1+ instances of QueryClauseType as open content.
|     Deserves annotation b/c specified behavior relies on open content.
|20050816 - Draft 27.

|119. (=Spec#66) LookupResponseType#pso: Remove maxOccurs=unbounded.
|20050816 - Draft 27.

|120. (=Spec#75) Add ErrorCode#invalidIdentifier and #alreadyExists (for addRequest#psoID).
|20050816 - Draft 27.