Re: [relax-ng] Re: Some ideas about type-assignment

[James Clark <jjc@jclark.com>]

> If our type-assignment spec has to provide "start-end detection", we will
probably
> have to define semantics of RELAX NG schemas without performing
normalization.
> I think that this is too difficult.  Rather, I think that "start-end
detection"
> should be built by implementors of data binding tools.
>
> In my understanding of Jonathan's message, XQuery does not require
"start-end
> detection".  I thus propose to omit two of the requirements in my
> message [1]
>
> >
> > - Type-assignment should be useful for data binding tools.
> ...
> >   3) uniquely determine which group/interleave/choice is applied
> >      to the content of each element and the value of each attribute,
> >      and

I agree with this.

James