RE: [security-services] XML Encryption guidance issue

[<Frederick.Hirsch@nokia.com>]

Scott

>Gary Ellison noted that usng an OOB symmetric key to encrypt the
encryption keys used is likely to be >useful in such a case to make the
process efficient.

Right, this fits in with not mandating particular key management
mechanisms.


> >Super-encryption, which means encrypting content that includes 
> >encrypted content, is not specified in the SAML specifications, but 
> >this does not mean it couldn't occur in a SOAP messaging component of

> >the system - but the SAML specifications are silent on the topic and
I 
> >believe this is appropriate.

>Well, it could happen with SAML quite easily such as an encrypted
assertion that contains an
>EncryptedID or EncryptedAttribute. The question is, do we need to say
anything about it? I'm not sure >why encrypting an element that happens
to have stuff from the XMLEnc spec in it is different from any >other
element.

I don't think much need be said in this case.


Regards, Frederick

Frederick Hirsch
Nokia