RE: [security-services] ECP operational mode and the identity provider discovery profile

["Jahan Moreh" <jmoreh@sigaba.com>]

It is already in the errata doc. We will bring this up in the next call and hopefully approve of the change quickly.

 

Jahan

 

 

------------------------------
Jahan Moreh
Chief Security Architect
310.288.2141

-----Original Message-----
From: prateek mishra [mailto:pmishra@principalidentity.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 09, 2005 10:43 AM
To: eric@projectliberty.org; security-services@lists.oasis-open.org; jmoreh@sigaba.com
Subject: [security-services] ECP operational mode and the identity provider discovery profile

I had taken an action at the last conference call (June 7) to respond to Eric's comment. I agree with his suggestion that "the relevant cell in the matrix should say OPTIONAL rather than N/A."

 

Jahan: could you please add this to the errata list.

 

- prateek

 

Comment from: eric@projectliberty.org

Name: Eric Tiffany
Title: Interop and Conformance Technical Lead
Organization: Liberty Alliance
Regarding Specification: Conformance

The Feature Matrix (Table 2), last row, lists Identity Provider Discovery as N/A in the ECP column.  However, the Profiles spec (line 725) notes that "The ECP MAY use the SAML identity provider discovery profile" to determine the IdP.

So I think that the relevant cell in the matrix should say OPTIONAL rather than N/A.