[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Subject: my ballot for GROUPS 6, 7, 8, 9
BALLOT ---------------------------------------------------------------------- All issue resolutions are mutually exclusive, so please choose one option for each issue. [UC-6-01:XMLProtocol] 1. Change requirement for binding to SOAP to binding to XML Protocol. (X) 2. Leave current binding to SOAP. 3. Remove mention of binding to either of these protocols. [UC-7-01:Enveloping] 1. Add proposed requirement [CR-7-01:Enveloping]. (X)2. Do not add this proposed requirement. Some care is needed on this issue. Are we proposing to build a general packaging infra-structure so SAML can "enclose" arbitrary XML payloads?? To me that seems to be far beyond the scope (and resources) of this group. [UC-7-02:Enveloped] (X)1. Add proposed requirement [CR-7-02:Enveloped]. 2. Do not add this proposed requirement. [UC-8-01:Intermediaries] (X)1. Add proposed requirement [CR-8-01:Intermediaries]. 2. Do not add this requirement to the document. [UC-8-02:IntermediaryAdd] (X)1. Add the given use-case scenario to the document. 2. Don't add this use-case scenario. We need to keep any "addition" real simple; assertions should be atomic but an intermediary can certainly add some new assertions. These new assertions may "depend upon" existing assertions. [UC-8-03:IntermediaryDelete] 1. Add the given use-case scenario to the document. (X)2. Don't add this use-case scenario. [UC-8-04:IntermediaryEdit] 1. Add this use-case scenario to the document. (X)2. Don't add this use-case scenario. [UC-8-05:AtomicAssertion] (X)1. Add the non-goal [CR-8-05:AtomicAssertion] to the document, and change use case scenarios to specify that intermediaries must treat assertions as atomic. 2. Don't add this non-goal. [UC-9-01:RuntimePrivacy] (X)1. Add the proposed non-goal [CR-9-01:RuntimePrivacy]. 2. Do not add this proposed non-goal. [UC-9-02:PrivacyStatement] 1. Add [CR-9-02-3-DisclosureMorgan] as a requirement. 2. Add [CR-9-02-2-DisclosureBlakley] as a requirement. (X)3. Add [CR-9-02-4-DisclosureMishra] as a requirement. 4. Add none of these as requirements. ------ Attachments are virus free! This message has been scanned for viruses at the originating end by Nemx Anti-Virus for MS Exchange Server/IMC http://www.nemx.com/products/antivirus
BALLOT ---------------------------------------------------------------------- All issue resolutions are mutually exclusive, so please choose one option for each issue. [UC-6-01:XMLProtocol] 1. Change requirement for binding to SOAP to binding to XML Protocol. (X) 2. Leave current binding to SOAP. 3. Remove mention of binding to either of these protocols. [UC-7-01:Enveloping] 1. Add proposed requirement [CR-7-01:Enveloping]. (X)2. Do not add this proposed requirement. Some care is needed on this issue. Are we proposing to build a general packaging infra-structure so SAML can "enclose" arbitrary XML payloads?? To me that seems to be far beyond the scope (and resources) of this group. [UC-7-02:Enveloped] (X)1. Add proposed requirement [CR-7-02:Enveloped]. 2. Do not add this proposed requirement. [UC-8-01:Intermediaries] (X)1. Add proposed requirement [CR-8-01:Intermediaries]. 2. Do not add this requirement to the document. [UC-8-02:IntermediaryAdd] (X)1. Add the given use-case scenario to the document. 2. Don't add this use-case scenario. We need to keep any "addition" real simple; assertions should be atomice but an intermediary can certainly add some new assertions. These new assertions may "depend upon" existing assertions. [UC-8-03:IntermediaryDelete] 1. Add the given use-case scenario to the document. (X)2. Don't add this use-case scenario. [UC-8-04:IntermediaryEdit] 1. Add this use-case scenario to the document. (X)2. Don't add this use-case scenario. [UC-8-05:AtomicAssertion] (X)1. Add the non-goal [CR-8-05:AtomicAssertion] to the document, and change use case scenarios to specify that intermediaries must treat assertions as atomic. 2. Don't add this non-goal. [UC-9-01:RuntimePrivacy] (X)1. Add the proposed non-goal [CR-9-01:RuntimePrivacy]. 2. Do not add this proposed non-goal. [UC-9-02:PrivacyStatement] 1. Add [CR-9-02-3-DisclosureMorgan] as a requirement. 2. Add [CR-9-02-2-DisclosureBlakley] as a requirement. (X)3. Add [CR-9-02-4-DisclosureMishra] as a requirement. 4. Add none of these as requirements.
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Powered by eList eXpress LLC