Comments to NDR Draft and Checklist

["Sylvia Webb" <swebb@gefeg.com>]

Mavis,

I rechecked with David Kruppke and he in fact did have one comment about the
latest NDR draft document.

It concernes the rules for BBIE elements and types.

There are contradictions between these rules: CTD3,CTN2,ELD8,ELN4.


CTD3 says: For every BBIE property a global complexType should be created.
CTN2 says: The name of these types must be of property term, qualifiers and
representation term.

This means, that for every BBIE including the qualified ones a complexType
should be created. And this is correct.

ELD8 says: The global element for a qualified BBIE has to be based on the
complexType for the "unqualified" BBIE.

This is wrong: It has to be based on the complexType for the "qualified"
BBIE.

Because ELD8 is wrong, ELN4 says the name of a global element for a
qualified BBIE has to be the same name as the undelying complexType prefixed
by the qualifier and "Type" removed.

If this element would be based on the complexType for a qualified BBIE then
the term "prefixed by the qualifier" had to be removed.

Regards,
Sylvia