RE: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy TModel comments

[Tom Bellwood <bellwood@us.ibm.com>]

Correct,

CR 32 now supercedes.


Thanks,
Tom Bellwood       Phone:  (512) 838-9957 (external);   TL:  678/9957
(internal)
Co-Chair, OASIS UDDI Specification TC
STSM - Emerging Technologies
IBM Corporation

"John Colgrave" <colgrave@hursley.ibm.com> on 06/24/2003 03:46:06 AM

To:    "'Luc Clement'" <lclement@windows.microsoft.com>, "'CAHUZAC Maud /
       FTR&D / US'" <maud.cahuzac@rd.francetelecom.com>,
       <uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org>
cc:
Subject:    RE: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy TModel comments





Luc,



I assume this will not be added to CR-002 given CR-032.



John Colgrave

IBM



-----Original Message-----
From: Luc Clement [mailto:lclement@windows.microsoft.com]
Sent: 05 May 2003 05:14
To: CAHUZAC Maud / FTR&D / US; uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: RE: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy TModel comments



Maud,



I was going through mail to look for items not covered and found that
your's hadn't been dealt with.



Each of the v2 and v3 specs are OK wrt the keys they use. I'll point out
that the key used in the v3 spec is a v3 derived key (i.e.
uuid:54AF30AE-9B61-385C-9D1D-AB572E72BFF2). The original tModel's v2 key
is: uuid:E59AE320-77A5-11D5-B898-0004AC49CC1E.



TC:

That said, while reviewing your note, I think I've identified an error with
the tModel's name whereby it should be have been named
"uddi-org:isReplacedBy_v3" rather than "uddi-org:isReplacedBy" given that
this tModel is a replacement, and that for purpose of consistency with
other similarly replaced tModels, it should have been renamed. If folks
agree, I'd propose that this be added to CR-002.

11.1.6.2                tModel Definition

Name:                          uddi-org:isReplacedBy <<< in error ???

Description:                 An identifier system used to point to the
entity, using UDDI keys, that is the logical replacement for the one in
which isReplacedBy is used.

UDDI Key (V3):             uddi:uddi.org:identifier:isReplacedBy

Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:54AF30AE-9B61-385C-9D1D-AB572E72BFF2

Categorization:            identifier

Checked:                     Yes





From:CAHUZAC Maud / FTR&D / US [mailto:maud.cahuzac@rd.francetelecom.com]
Sent: Thursday, April 03, 2003 17:22
To: 'uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org'
Subject: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy TModel comments

Hi everybody,



I have 2 little comments regarding the CR "isReplacedBy tModel"
(uddi-spec-tc-cr010-isreplacedby-20030304.doc):



First, in the UDDI V2.0 part, section 5.4.2 10.4 Example of Use, I don't
understand the value of the tModelKey in the keyedReference.

I thought this value was the TModelkey of the "IsReplacedBy" TModel :



<tModel tModelKey=uuid:64C756D1-3374-4E00-AE83-EE12E38FAE63>

...

  <name>uddi-org:publication</name>

...

  <categoryBag>

    <!-- Use uddi-org:IsReplacedBy to indicate that this tModel (the uddi
V1 publication tModel) is

         logically replaced by the V2 publication tModel. -->

    <keyedReference keyName="uddi-org:publication_v2"

      keyValue="uuid:A2F33B65-2D66-4088-ABC7-914D0E05EB9E"

      tModelKey="uuid:54AF30AE-9B61-385C-9D1D-AB572E72BFF2"/> (instead of
"uuid:E59AE320-77A5-11D5-B898-0004AC49CC1E")

  </categoryBag>

...

</tModel>



Also, in the UDDI V3.0 part, section 5.5.1.4 11.1.6.4 Example of Use, the
value of the tModelKey in the keyedReference

should be "uddi.org:categorization:isReplacedBy" instead of
"uddi:uddi.org:identifier:isReplacedBy" (am I wrong?)



Thanks,



Maud





Maud Cahuzac,

Technical Analyst
france telecom R&D, LLC
801 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 500
South San Francisco, CA 94080
Phone:(650) 875-1577
Fax :(650) 875-1505

Email: maud.cahuzac@rd.francetelecom.com