Minutes April 28, 2005

[Greg Pavlik <greg.pavlik@oracle.com>]

Day Two

Agenda
-Review CF comments
-Transactions
-Future meetings/schedule

Review of CF comments

Comment one: on faults. This is covered by issue resolution on faults.

Comment two: on WS-Addressing, resolved by issue resolution on addressing

comment three: should recoverParticipant be changed to replaceParticipant?

Motion by Greg Pavlik recoverParticipant replaced by replaceParticipant. 
Motion seconded by Mark Little.

comment four: Mark Little makes motion to replace recoverRegistration 
with replaceRegistration. Greg Pavlik seconds motion.

comment on diagram: needs to be updated. Martin asks if the diagrams are 
necessary if we have tables. Editorial AI.

comment on asw namespace: fixed. Editorial action: insert text 
indicating that WSDL is normative over examples. AI for Martin to search 
minutes for instructions.

comment on subprotocols and list of participants: editorial action to 
make Figure 6 correct.

References are dangling: editorial AI to fix.

Long discussion about whether registration may be used independent of 
the activity concept may be independent. Mark Little makes motion that 
all CF interfaces must be contextualized. Doug Bunting seconds.

Tony identified that there is a problem with the WS-Context status type: 
it appears to be in the the assertion type. This is logged as issue that 
needs fixing.

Tony notes that In Context schema, element assertion doesn't seem to be 
used. Greg Pavlik makes motion to remove assertion element. Tony 
Fletcher seconds. AI for Kevin to remove.

Tony notes that assertion type doesn't include wsu:id attribute anymore. 
Issue filed.

Tony notes that element service-ref isn't used; Greg: it will go away as 
we adopt WS-Addressing.

Tony: schema for CF needs participant list and protocols. Tony Fletcher 
makes motion to remove any element from CF Registration context. Mark 
Little seconds.

Transactions

Mark gives presentation on transactions.

Mark motions that TXM be split into separate, independent 
specifications. Greg Pavlik seconds. Martin asks if TXM disappears.

Greg Pavlik motions we move forward with ACID model and leave the other 
two alone. Mark seconds. AI to editors to adopt the broken out ACID 
model to use the Context/CF updates.

Andy Moyer, director of biz dev at development, presenting for OASIS. 
There is a presentation. Web events are useful. Press releases 
coordinated; good contact for education/awareness.

Future Meetings/Schedule

Next F2F is tentatively scheduled for the week of JavaOne 30 June, July 
1, hosted by Sun.

Oracle volunteers to host in September in New Jersey.

Everyone should be aware that we are on the new TC process. Please 
review the rules/terminology.

AI to editors: OASIS template needs to be applied.

AI implementation subgroup: should consider how ACID model can be 
incorporated into interop scenarios.

Greg Pavlik makes motion to adopt latest editorial draft of CF as 
committee draft (email dated 4-27-2005). Mark Little seconds. Motion 
tabled until next meeting to allow people to read the spec.

Aim end of May for Context for committee spec status
JavaOne for CF for committee spec status; three transaction specs 
separated by then.