Agenda update for Dec. 16

[Diane Jordan <drj@us.ibm.com>]

Here is our agenda for the meeting today
and a summary of what was decided in yesterday's meeting.
Proposed agenda for Dec. 16 
Requested discussions  
-> Issue 160 
  
 Review all remaining open issues
by category (alphabetical order) as time allows.

Update from WS-Choreography 

Schedule 
On Thursday we will reserve some time to
discuss the schedule and possible new  checkpoints we may want to
establish.

Next f2f meeting:  choices based on
last discussion are the week of Feb. 21, week of Mar 7 or week of Mar 15
(school break time for some) 
 Summary
of Dec 15 Meeting
•         Issue
145 proposal passed with note that further work is required on the specific
language. 
•        Issue
12.1 proposal passed.  Yaron to open it and 12.2 for the properties
related issue.  He will also open a new issue to clarify rethrow language.

•        Issue
2.  Ivana will continue to work on the proposal.  
•        New
issue proposed by Alex: vote on whether it is a bug deferred to next meeting
so people can consider it more.  
•        Issue
139 – general agreement in discussion that we should address this by adding
cautionary language in the spec rather than by trying to fix the issue.

•        Issue
96 – some agreement that this should be addressed by cautionary language
or note to implementers but more consideration required.
•        Issue
11.1 proposal discussed by Alex.  Straw poll:
•        Should
we get rid of assign.  Y=3, N=15
•        Do
we want to fix the extensibility of assign 
•        With
the proposal in Alex’s email.  Y=11, N=6
•        By
providing assign with extensibility without copy. Y=5, N=11
•        Do
we want to expand the BPEL native data manipulation operation boundary.
Y= 12, N=6        
 


Regards, Diane
IBM  Emerging Internet Software Standards
drj@us.ibm.com
(919)254-7221 or 8-444-7221, Mobile: 919-624-5123, Fax 845-491-5709