Re: [wsbpel] Issue - 147 - Error in description of the resolution

["Yaron Y. Goland" <ygoland@bea.com>]

The key vote is 147.4, your notes say:

Amendment – issue 147.4:  move yaron’s proposal, w/o name.
Amend: Alex – change to have two activities
Amendment to amendment does not pass
Amendment to 147 not required – base proposal includes appropriate text

147.4 asked the question of - should there be one flow activity with an 
attribute or two flow activities, one for serial and one for parallel? 
Alex tried to amend to have two activities (e.g. get rid of parallel), 
that vote failed and so we stayed with one activity using a parallel 
attribute.

	Thanks,

		Yaron

Diane Jordan wrote:
> The error seems to have originated in the notes I kept during the meeting. 
>  During the disucssion, Alex proposed an amendment to the schema based on an 
> email he wrote - you accepted as friendly.  I cut and pasted the relevant 
> portion of the email (at Alex's direction) into the notes I was keeping on the 
> board at the meeting (attached below).  It included the statement "Note: the 
> parallel attribute is now dropped.", however, it may be the cut and paste was 
> not accurate.      
> The full text of Alex's email is here: 
> http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsbpel/email/archives/200505/msg00176.html 
> 
> It might be good to get confirmation from Alex that this was a chair error.  ;-)  
> This is the file I had up on the board at the meeting to keep track of amendments -
> Here is the relevant text for 147:
> Issue 147
> Motion:  Adopt proposal from Yaron for 147
> Second: Alex
> With amendments:
> Amendment – change proposal so that no fault is thrown when start value is 
> larger than final value and do not iterate
> Amendment: Leave forEach to have variable declared on implicit scope ala event 
> handlers – update 204 to include forEach in its resolution.  
>  
> Amendment:  make link behavior for forEach the same as for while (section 12.5, 
> last paragraph).  
> Accepted as friendly amendment.  
> 
> Amendment:  Alex email regarding schema:
> _Note:_ the parallel attribute is now dropped.]
> 
>     <complexType name="tIterator">
>         <complexContent>
>             <extension base="bpws:tExtensibleElements">
>                 <sequence _minOccurs="0"_>
>                     <element name="startCounterValue"
>                              type="bpws:tExpression"/>
>                     <element name="finalCounterValue"
>                              type="bpws:tExpression"/>
>                 </sequence>
>             </extension>
>         </complexContent>
>     </complexType>
>  
> Accepted as friendly amendment.
> 
> Amendment
> Remove language in proposal that specified the use of number and round xpath 
> functions for xpath 1.0 expressions.  
> Accepted as friendly amendment.  
> 
> Do not allow minoccurs=0.  Make start and final mandatory.  This results in 
> getting rid of iterator wrapper.
> Accepted with no objections.
> 
> 
> Amendment:
> 1. Eliminate serial for each, remove attributes, etc related to it.
> Second – Harvey
> Does not pass
> 
>  2. Do not allow minoccurs=0.  Make start and final mandatory.  This results in 
> getting rid of iterator wrapper.
> Second - Yuzo
> Passes with no objections.
> Amendment to amendment:  Do not allow minoccurs=0 only.  
> Second – Alex
> Amendment to amendment does not pass.
> 
> Amendment:  consider description in counter proposal from Dieter to consider the 
> use of iterator variables instead of counter variables.  Sub issues can be 
> created to add details if necessary based on discussion.  
> Friendly amendment:  change to consider the use of alias based iterator 
> variables.  
> Amendment – not passed.
> 
> Amendment – issue 147.4:  move yaron’s proposal, w/o name.
> Amend: Alex – change to have two activities
> Amendment to amendment does not pass
> Amendment to 147 not required – base proposal includes appropriate text
> 
>  Amendment – call activity “for”
> Does not pass (means 147.1 is adopted)
> 
> Issue 147.3 – describes current proposal
> Amendment – change proposal so that no fault is thrown when start value is 
> larger than final value and do not iterate
> Second – Danny
> Yaron accepts as friendly amendment
> 
> Issue 147.6 – proposal says a non-extended version of the forEach activity MUST 
> include both start and final counter values.   No change
> 
> Issue 147.5 – 147 proposal requires the child be a scope and that the counter 
> variable be defined implicitly on that scope.  
> 
> If 204 gives us a different solution then we can always come back later and amend.
> 
> Amendment: Leave forEach to have variable declared on implicit scope ala event 
> handlers – update 204 to include forEach in its resolution.  
> Friendly amendment.
>  
> 
> Regards, Diane
> IBM  Emerging Internet Software Standards
> drj@us.ibm.com
> (919)254-7221 or 8-444-7221, Mobile: 919-624-5123, Fax 845-491-5709
> 
> 
> 
> *"Yaron Y. Goland" <ygoland@bea.com>*
> 
> 06/13/2005 06:28 PM
> Please respond to
> ygoland
> 
> 
> 	
> To
> 	wsbpeltc <wsbpel@lists.oasis-open.org>, "Furniss, Peter" 
> <peter.furniss@choreology.com>, "Fletcher, Tony" <Tony.Fletcher@choreology.com>
> cc
> 	
> Subject
> 	[wsbpel] Issue - 147 - Error in description of the resolution
> 
> 
> 	
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> I think there has been a miscommunication about what was decided at the
> F2F. The group explicitly voted to keep the parallel attribute, not as
> reported in the issues list.
> 
>                 Thanks,
> 
>                                  Yaron
> 
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
> 
> Join CEO Alfred Chuang and CTO Mark Carges on June 15 for a unique online
> event, giving you the first look at a new category of enterprise software
> built specifically for Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA).
> 
> Register Now.  It's Free!
> 
> http://www.bea.com/events/june15
> 
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that
> generates this mail.  You may a link to this group and all your TCs in OASIS
> at:
> https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php
> 
> 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Join CEO Alfred Chuang and CTO Mark Carges on June 15 for a unique online 
event, giving you the first look at a new category of enterprise software 
built specifically for Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA).

Register Now.  It's Free!

http://www.bea.com/events/june15