RE: [wsrf] Groups - WSRF_IssueList_2004may12.doc uploaded

["Murray, Bryan P." <bryan.murray@hp.com>]

I have updated issue WSRF3 (second paragraph below) and added WSRF45.

Bryan



Issue WSRF3: Specify whether GetResourceProperty returns fault or empty
element

The specification does not define the behavior for GetResourceProperty
when a property is defined in a property document schema with
minOccurs='0' and the property document currently has no instance of the
property. Two behaviors might be expected in this case: return an empty
message, or return a fault. The same issue exists in
GetMultipleResourceProperties.

There is need for clarification of how to know when a property is
nillable, what should be returned when a property is nillable and the
value of the property is nil, and under what circumstances a nil value
is returned. In WS-ResourceLifetime, the TerminationTime property
description talks about returning a nil value under some circumstances.





Issue WSRF45: Add elementFormDefault to all schemas

The attribute 'elementFormDefault' is missing from schema element for
the schemas in the following files: WS-ServiceGroup_submission.wsdl,
WS-ResourceProperties_submission.wsdl,
WS-ResourceLifetime_submission.wsdl,
WS-ResourceLifetime_submission.xsd, WS-BaseFaults_submission.xsd.

Specifications
*	Several

Proposed Recommendations
Add the 'elementFormDefault="qualified"' to the next version of the
files listed above.

Status: Open
Contact: Jarek Gawor


-----Original Message-----
From: Jarek Gawor [mailto:gawor@mcs.anl.gov] 
Sent: Wednesday, May 12, 2004 11:00 AM
To: wsrf@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: RE: [wsrf] Groups - WSRF_IssueList_2004may12.doc uploaded


Hi,

I think the WSRF3 issue needs to be further clarified to describe
exactly what happens also in cases where nillable="true" is set.

Also, as another issue it seems that WS-ServiceGroup_submission.wsdl,
WS-ResourceProperties_submission.wsdl,
WS-ResourceLifetime_submission.wsdl,
WS-ResourceLifetime_submission.xsd, WS-BaseFaults_submission.xsd are
missing 'elementFormDefault="qualified"' attribute on xsd:schema
element.

Jarek