Notes from the OASIS WSRF TC Face-to-Face
meeting
6th June 2005
Roll Call
The roll call is kept on the TC web site under the meeting
record.
See http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrf/event.php?event_id=7737
Confirm minute taker
Tim Banks is taking the minutes.
Approve of minutes of May 16th
Face-to-Face
See: http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/download.php/12766
There were no comments and no objections to
approving the minutes.
Call for AOB
None.
Action Review
(IanR) Regarding the following actions:
(Editors) Follow this new instruction about the soap headers in examples; only
include required wsa:action element. (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issues WSRF110 and
WSRF111 to open. (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(IanR) Update acknowledgements text and distribute to editors. (Done during F2F
prior to adopting CD).
(DaveS) Raise an issue to take care of the WS-N Dependency. (112) (Done during
F2F prior to adopting CD).
(DaveS) Propose new issue to discuss namespaces and versioning (113). (Done
during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(DaveS) Need a new issue to decide on action uris for faults (114). (Done
during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Create a new issue for
SG containing RP document (115) (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(IanR) Fix statement in WS-RAP about requirement for basefaults. (Done during
F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issue WSRF109 to
resolved (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Issue WSRF105 Move to
Closed – no action. (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Create a new issue for
SG containing RP document. (115) (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Close issues WSRF89,
WSRF91, WSRF92, WSRF99, WSRF101, WSRF97,
WSRF98, WSRF102, WSRF63, WSRF106, WSRF22, WSRF44, WSRF58, WSRF59,
WSRF65, WSRF69, WSRF87, WSRF104. (Done)
(Bryan) Move issue WSRF107 to
resolved (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issue WSRF110 to
resolved (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issue WSRF111 to
close as covered by the resolution to issue WSRF100. (Done during F2F prior to
adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issue WSRF112 to
close (no action) (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issue WSRF113 to
resolved. (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Raise a new issue.
(116) to describe removal of embodiments 3.2 and move to resolved. (Done during
F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issues WSRF114 and
WSRF110 to resolved. (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issues WSRF103 and
WSRF109 to closed. (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(Bryan) Move issues WSRF113 and
WSRF115 to resolved. (Done during F2F prior to adopting CD).
(IanR) Does everyone agree that these were
all closed before the CD specs were approved?
No Objections.
(IanR) In respect of:
(SteveG) Review minutes from last face-to-face re: element children only in RP
doc (Issue WSRF95).
(IanR) Steve is not on the call. I took a
look at this (See below) and WSRF95 is fully implemented. We need a new issue
if we want to consider changes.
No objections.
Action: (SteveG)
(Steve G) Raise new issue for further relaxation of RPDoc constraints.
(Tim) Construct a Printer/ShoppingCart example based on Service group to enable
others to judge. Done (see below)
New
issues to consider - Bryan
None
Summary
of spec status - Ian
(IanR) We discovered that OASIS will accept
our short names, so artifacts have been uploaded. We can now vote on accepting
Committee drafts as public review drafts.
Ballots are prepared and we can do this
between telecons.
Action: (Ian/Editors)
Make updates needed for Public review level.
Resource metadata specification – Tom
(TomM) We need to go through the
presentation that was scheduled for the face-to-face
(See http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrf/download.php/12696)
(IanR) Are there any objections to Tom
going ahead to produce a draft specification?
None.
Action (TomM)
Post revised draft of specification.
Issue
review - Chair
None
Update
on Primer - Tim
See presentation here: http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrf/download.php/12969
(IanR) We should model the printer jobs as ServiceGroup
Entries.
(TimB) That’s option 1: there are problems
if the memberservice EPR points to nothing.
(DaveS) I like option 3: ServiceGroup
Entries are an abstract of the info in the Print_Job. Print_Job is a WS
Resource which can be the target of a ‘cancel’.
(IanR) We should separate the issue of a
by-reference vs by-value collection from the way it’s updated.
(DaveS) If I wanted to model the chapters
of a book, it would need an ‘UpdateChapter’ operation with a ‘chapterId’ parameter,
or use UpdateResourceProperties.
(TimB) Right: we don’t have other way to
deal with repeated child elements besides application-specific parameters, or
making them into WS-Resources, or using UpdateReosurceProperties which replaces
all of the child elements. The latter is feasible only up to a certain scale,
maybe 5 or so children.
(IanR) Then we can we use the Printer as a
good example of ServiceGroup via option 3?
(TimB) It’s not a good example of ServiceGroup
because the Jobs can only belong to one printer. Services can be long to many ServiceGroups,
and to the same ServiceGroup more than once. We should choose another example
for SG.
Action:
(Chairs) Continue discussion
AOB
None
Straggler
Roll Call & Close
Closed 2:05 eastern time
Next telecon is on June 13th.
Summary of actions
Action: (Ian/Editors)
Make updates needed for Public review level.
Action (TomM)
Post revised draft of specification.