Minutes of the teleconfernce call held on 3rd October

[Tim Banks <tim_banks@uk.ibm.com>]

The minutes are stored here:
http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/download.php/14807/WSRF%20TC%20%5B3Oct05%5D%20notes%5B1%5D.pdf

and attached.

(See attached file: WSRF TC [3Oct05] notes[1].htm)

Regards, Tim Banks.

Title: WSRF TC notes

Notes from the OASIS WSRF TC
Teleconference
3^rd October 2005

Roll Call

 

The roll call is kept on the TC web site under the meeting record.

See http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrf/event.php?event_id=7746

 

The meeting is quorate.

 

Confirm minute taker

John Fuller is taking the minutes.

 

 

Approve of minutes of September 14^th-16^th Face To Face

 

See: http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/download.php/14504

 

There were no comments and no objections to approving the minutes.

 Call For AOB

Issues Secretary Bryan is on vacation, Ian volunteers to take over AIs.

Action Review

(Ian) Find new owner for RMD specification.

(Bryan/Dave/Ian) post a queries to the WSDM/OGSI/WSRF communities/lists to solicit interest in RM.

(IanR) Dan Jemiolo from ibm/wsdm tc is to take over ownership of the RMD spec

(New RMD editor) Post revised draft of RMD Carried Fwd from July 25th. Carry Fwd

(New RMD editor) Write new text for resolution to issue wsrf 118.(cut/copy/paste for RMD to go in AppNotes.) Carried Fwd from June 27th.  Carry Fwd
(Bryan) Move following issues to resolved: 134, 135, 136, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147 to resolved. Done

 

 

(Bryan) Update resolution to issue 127. Done

(Editors) Update specs according to resolutions. Done

[PS: Ian took the action to close issues that were included in the PR02 drafts.

Subsequent to the call, the following were closed:

WSRF110: BaseFaults does not allow open content

WSRF124: WS-Addressing schemaLocation has a trailing “/”

WSRF125: PR Comment – Wording change for requirement 1

WSRF126: PR Comment – Question of intent for requirement 2

WSRF127: PR Comment – Why MUST for “Resource Action Pattern”?

WSRF132: PR Comment – how does permission to access a property affect the response of GetMultipleResourceProperties?

WSRF133: PR Comment – clarify the fault to be returned when a request specifies a QName that cannot exist in the resource property document

WSRF134: PR Comment – correct type of the Dialect attribute on a QueryExpression

WSRF135: PR Comment – reference to work in progress

WSRF136: PR Comment – clarify description of QueryExpressionDialect

WSRF137: Allow the MemberServiceEPR to be optional element in a ServiceGroup

WSRF138: Typo in title of section 5.1.1

WSRF139: Number of messages needed to retrieve the content of a service group

WSRF140: Constraints on use of schema for resource properties document

WSRF141: Update WS-Addressing namespace to Candidate Recommendation namespace from W3C

WSRF142: Name of WSDL message part

WSRF143: Context of XPath in QueryResourceProperties

WSRF144: QueryResourceProperties does not have any dialect that is guaranteed to be supported

WSRF145: Editorial comments from HP on BaseFaults

WSRF146: Editorial comments from HP on ResourceProperties

WSRF147: ResourceProperties Comments from Ricoh

WSRF148: Resource comments from Ricoh

WSRF149: ServiceGroup comments from Ricoh

WSRF150: ResourceLifetime comments from Ricoh

WSRF152: Fujitsu Public Review comments

]

 

Spec editor tasks (Ian)

The electronic ballot 10 days ago to approve specifications resolved to move to a new committee draft and review this (02) draft. Information to be zipped and sent to tc administration.

New 15 day public review period will be started.

Editors to perform additional tasks first:

       Each of the specification editors to add pr02 drafts to the database in word format, html and pdf versions from those, wsdl and xsd as well.

Also need a report of changes since pr01.

One difference is that pr02 won't contain updates to the appnote spec.

Action: Editors.

 

New issues

WSRF153: PR Comment – Cut-and-past error on line 501 of ServiceGroups

(Ian) Subscription instead of ServiceGroup entry. This should be fixed in the PR02 draft. Any Objections?

None.

Action: (Ian) Move to resolved (Tim/Dave)

 

Progress Report on AppNotes and Primer

(TimB)Primer is being updated and should be finished in two weeks.

 

Appnotes

(IanR) Roger is working on it, but isn’t on the call.

 

Straggler Roll Call

 

Closed 12:30

 

Summary of actions

 

(Dan) Post revised draft of RMD Carried Fwd from July 25th.
(Dan) Write new text for resolution to issue wsrf 118.(cut/copy/paste for RMD to go in AppNotes.) Carried Fwd from June 27^th

(SG Editors) Include resolution of wsrf153 in CD spec.

(Ian) Move issue wsrf153 to resolved.