RE: [wsrf] text for appnotes, issue 20

["Murray, Bryan P." <bryan.murray@hp.com>]

All of the following are valid locations for the
ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification element within a notification
message. B and D make use of the WSDM event wrapper. C and D make use of
the WSN event wrapper. A is the simplest possible value change
notification.

It is conceivable that other event wrappers may be used. The AppNotes
text just needs to be clear that the
ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification element may be found in many
places in the notification message.

(A)
<s:Body>
  <wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
    ...
  </wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
</s:Body>

(B)
<s:Body>
  <muws1:ManagementEvent>
    ...
    <wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
      ...
    </wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
  </muws1:ManagementEvent>
</s:Body>

(C)
<s:Body>
  <baseN:Notify>
    <baseN:NotificationMessage>
      ...
      <baseN:Message>
        <wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
          ...
        </wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
      </baseN:Message>
    </baseN:NotificationMessage>
  </baseN:Notify>
</s:Body>

(D)
<s:Body>
  <baseN:Notify>
    <baseN:NotificationMessage>
      ...
      <baseN:Message>
        <muws1:ManagementEvent>
          ...
          <wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
            ...
          </wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification>
        </muws1:ManagementEvent>
      </baseN:Message>
    </baseN:NotificationMessage>
  </baseN:Notify>
</s:Body>


Bryan
 

-----Original Message-----
From: Roger Menday [mailto:r.menday@fz-juelich.de] 
Sent: Monday, November 28, 2005 8:20 AM
To: wsrf@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: [wsrf] text for appnotes, issue 20 


Hi,

I am struggling to write some coherent text for section 3.6.1.2 of the
AppNotes (resolution to issue 20).

What I understand :

The wsrf-rp:ResourcePropertyValueChangeNotification element MUST appear
*somewhere* in the Nofication message. However, it really can appear
anywhere.

So, an example notification might be

<RPValueChangeNotification .. />

or,

<nofify>
<RPValueChangeNotification .. />
</notify>

or,

<nofify>
<cbeelemnt>
...
<RPValueChangeNotification .. />

</cbelement>
</notify>

etc ...

Which one is correct ?

What does a CBE element actually look like ? Should this level of detail
be in the AppNotes section ?

The header to this section is currently : "Value-change notification
message in WSDM event format (Management Event) common base events
format". This doesn't sound nice.

"Accomodating other formats for the Value-change notification message"

??

I would appreciate (and need) some help here :) ...

Roger