RE: [wsrm] REL-13 proposal

[<magdolna.gerendai@nokia.com>]

Hi all,

Sorry, I was not enough clear here. As you see from the other mail I sent, my opinion is, that we should consider, what elements beyond the reliable messaging we define, especially the From/To elements are not needed. Not only because they don't give more information, but are not enough for routing either (which is out of scope furthermore).
This requirement in my understanding is a spec. issue and during the specification we should consider, what to keep from the input specification. 

br,
Magdolna

-----Original Message-----
From: ext [mailto:magdolna.gerendai@nokia.com]
Sent: June 25,2003 17:37
To: marc.andrue.goodner@sap.com; wsrm@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: RE: [wsrm] REL-13 proposal


Hi Marc,

I think, we should keep this spec. requirement. The "From/To" elements are not enough for routing alone. 

br,
Magdolna


-----Original Message-----
From: ext Goodner, Marc Andrue [mailto:marc.andrue.goodner@sap.com]
Sent: June 18,2003 13:25
To: wsrm@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: [wsrm] REL-13 proposal


Proposal: Close with no action. Rational is that we should pay careful attention to this issue as we determine which elements should be required/optional and what their fault characteristics are, but there is nothing we can reflect in the specification directly for this issue.

Regards,
Marc g

Issue REL-13
Title: Use of elements beyond WSRM
Description: The existing specification contains a number of elements that may apply to many use cases beyond reliable messaging. For example,