Prelim Minutes WSRM TC Conference Call
Feb
03, 2004
The meeting of the WSRM TC took place by teleconference
Tuesday Jan 27 2004, from 5:30 to 6:45 PM Eastern Standard Time
(UTC - 5)
Conference call Dial-in number
: Toll number (only): 1-512-225-3050 Participant code: 89772
0
Draft
Agenda:
Draft Agenda to WSRM TC Conference Call
1 Roll Call
2 Minutes Discussion
2.1 Appointment of Minute Taker
2.2 Approval of previous meeting minutes
3 Discussion of New Orleans Meeting and
Conference papers
4 Discussion of Action Items - http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrm/download.php/5090/Action%20Item%20List%20from%20Jan%20Face%20To%20Face%20Meeting.htm
5 Discussions of Issues
Agenda approved
1
Roll
Call
Attendance:
Meeting was quorate.
2
Minutes
Discussion
2.1 Appointment
of Minute Taker
Tom Rutt will take
minutes.
The minutes will serve for issue resolutions.
2.2 Approval
of previous meeting minutes
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrm/download.php/5223/MinutesWSRMTC-012704.htm
xx moved to accept the Jan 27 minutes. yy seconded.
No opposition, f2f minutes approved.
3
Discussion of New Orleans Meeting and Conference
Tom Rutt received the
following mail from Oasis Staff:
Hello Chairs,
This is the preliminary schedule that we have
for TC meetings in New
Orleans. As you can imagine, we need to guarantee a
quantity of sleeping
rooms in order to get
the meeting room space at no charge, so it's important
that I get a final
commitment. Please confirm the number of TC members that
have booked their rooms
and please confirm the meeting times for your TC. I
can not confirm meeting
rooms until reservations are made. Also, please let
me know if you need 1/2
day instead of full day, plan to meet from
8:00am-12:00pm or 1:00-5:00pm. Thank you for your prompt
reply.
Regards,
Dee
|
|
25 April
Sunday
|
26 April
Monday
|
27 April
Tuesday
|
28 April
Wednesday
|
29 April
Thursday
|
Friday
|
|
Room
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Small
Room 1--Audubon (holds 18)
|
|
|
|
OASIS
Board (10)
|
OASIS
Board (10)
|
|
|
Large
Room 2--Balcony I (holds 30)
|
|
|
|
WSRM
TC (10)
|
WSRM
TC (10)
|
|
|
Large
Room 3 Balcony L(holds 30)
|
|
|
|
Electronic
Court Filing TC (13)
|
Electronic
Court Filing TC (13), Integrated Justice Legal XML (30)
|
|
Large
Room 4--Balcony M (holds 30)
|
|
|
|
Emergency
Management TC (15) 8-12PM;
ebXML Registry TC 1:00-5:00PM
(6)
|
WS-CAF
TC (15-20)
|
|
|
Small
Room 5--Beauregard (holds 18)
|
|
|
|
XDI
TC
|
ebXML Registry TC (6)
|
|
|
Large
Room 6--Balcony N(holds 30)
|
|
|
|
WS-CAFTC 8:00-12:00 (15); ebXML
CPPA 1:00-5:00PM
|
CAM TC
|
|
|
Small
Room 7--Jackson (holds 18)
|
|
|
|
ebXML Messaging TC (10-12)
|
ebXML Messaging TC (10-12)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Waiting
List; LI-XML, WSDM
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Last
Updated 2/03/04
|
|
Need to discuss finalization of panel.
4
Discussion of Action Item Status from Jan F2F
meeting
Action Item List Status - from Jan Face To Face
Meeting
1.
ACTION: Need to ensure faults in general being Cleaned up Sunil will try to
get a proposal to clean up fault text before the end of the F2f.. - DONE
2.
Action: Iwasa to apply changes for reo 44, then we will change status after done done 3.1.1.
3.
Action: Iwasa is to produce a
change barred version of all the changes made from the 1-06 document. Use compare documents
under Edit to do it. - done
4.
ACTION: Sunil took action to come up with additions to the
model text for section 2.1 by Friday. Done Suni
updated section 2 for polling
5.
ACTION: Jacques will make a proposal to fix these group
semantic concerns. Done, sent proposed updated wording to Iwasa,
which he has consolidated in last spec draft. See section 2.2 ("Groups of
messages and message identity").
6.
ACTION: Iwasa needs to remove the
sentence on the description of invalidExipiryTime
stating it is sent when the message expires. done at 4
7.
ACTION: Iwasa has to factor in the
new syntax for the message Id schema in section 3.3. The sections need to be rearranged since some
items have been changed from elements to attributes., and some of the names
have changed - done
8.
ACTION: Sunil will provide text to include in the
specification for what is not covered by existing protocol for request/response
support. done, see AI 9
9.
ACTION: Sunil will put a statement in a note regarding reply pattern
for one-way wsdl operations, to add to the operation/replypattern table. Done text needs to be incorporated by
Iwasa.
Last para in 2.9 needs
to be recast as footnote on Supported entries in the request resonse row.
10. ACTION:
Iwasa will change MAY OPTIONAL for parameters to use
cardinality instead, for the entire document. open
11. ACTION: Sunil will provide a
complete spec of the wsdl extension feature before we
decided on the resolution. Action Item closed, will discuss Issue later.
Done Sunil sent in
updated proposal to list To discuss as part of
resolution to issue 49.
12. ACTION; Sunil will incorporate
the processing faults into his fault proposal for review on Friday morning.
done see AI 14
13. ACTION: Iwasa
to change, in the first sentence of definition of guranteed
delivery to: A message submitted to the sending rmp
with guaranteed delivery requested, will either be delivered by the receiving rmp, or the sending rmp will
notify the submitter of failure. done section 2.3
14. ACTION: Sunil will provide a
new section 4, - done
15. Action: Iwasa
to add sentence: This element has cardinality zero or 1 in the rm-request message. done in 3.3
16. ACTION:
Iwasa to add explanation for the table rows in
Section 3: e.g., for cardinality: cardinality is a constraint on the number of
instances of an item type which may be present in an enclosing item. - open
17. Action: Iwasa
will finish updating section 3 to fully reflect the syntax changes for message
references. - done
18. Action: Sunil will update
the schema. done and put in latest spec
19. ACTION :Sunil will come up with text to resolve this issue
on clarification of Poll semantics.. done,.
20. ACTION:
Iwasa will add sub-section to section 3 for Fault
element. Sunil and Jacques will help Iwasa Still open
21. ACTION: Sunil will update to
have the soap 1.2 mapping of ws-reliability will not
use the rm:fault element,
but instead will use the soap 1.2 Subcode element.
Done
Done. Ive mentioned in the Section 4.0 of my write-up. Iwasa need to add this in Section 3 when describing the
Fault element.
22. ACTION:
Iwasa will put soap 1.2 statement in the new section
in 3 on rm:fault element.
still open
23. ACTION: Sunil will
incorporate amended fault proposal into the Schema and into the new text for
section 4. Done see AI 14
24. ACTION: Iwasa
will update section 3 to accommodate the new fault proposal Same as Action
Item 20. Close as duplicate
25. ACTION: Sunil add text that
a response to a poll may not coexist with a rm:request header.
Done see AI 19
26. ACTION: Iwasa
make the changes requested by Jacques for section 2 lead in. - done
27. ACTION: Jacques will add
clarification of sender/receiver synch of termination criteria for his homework on
clarifying group termination. Done, provided to Iwasa
as an updated draft, where the Group termination section has been significantly
reworded.
28. ACTION:
Iwasa will start working on new examples. still open. Sunil
will send the roughed out schema examples.
Tom Will help send the examples to Iwasa. Still Open
Sunil will send out new schema at the end of this meeting.
29.
Action: Editors will produce up to date issues list by the next
meeting. done
The action items were?? be
reflected.
New issues list posted by Mark G as
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrm/download.php/5273/wsrm-issues-2004-02-03.html
5
Discussion
of Issues
5.1 Issue
49 WSDL Annotation
5.2 Ack and Fault Response Contents