[wsrp-wsia] Minutes for 9 January 2003 Meeting

[Steven Smith <ssmith@capitol-college.edu>]

WSRP Members Attendance:
Aickin, Sasha            Plumtree           Yes
Allamaraju, Subbu       BEA                Yes
Atkinson, Olin             Novell               Yes
Blich, Amir                  SAP                Yes
Braun, Chris                Novell               Yes
Brooks, Rex                Starbourne        Yes
Cox, T. J.                    Novell                Yes
Cox, William                BEA                 Yes
Dirking, Brian               Stellent             Yes
Drye, Stephen              Art Technology  Yes
Fillicetti, Gino               Bowstreet          No
Freedman, Michael       Oracle               Yes
Jacob, Richard             IBM                   Yes
Klein, Jon                    Reed-Elsevier     Yes
Kramer, Andre             Citrix                  Yes
Kropp, Alan                 Vignette Corporation    Yes
Leue, Carsten              IBM                    Yes
Machak, Dan               Tibco                  Yes
Martin, Monica             Drake Certivo      Yes
Mitsuoka, Madoka        Fujitsu               Yes
Nolan, Adam                Reed-Elsevier     Yes
Palas, Petr                  Moravia IT           Yes
Pugsley, Ken               Peoplesoft          No
Ramesh, Raj               CommerceOne    Yes
Randhawa, Sunit          Fujitsu               No
Ratcliffe, Nigel              Factiva              Yes
Rudnicki, Joe               U.S. Navy         Yes
Schaeck, Thomas        IBM                  Yes
Shumaker, Gennady    SAP                 Yes
Smith, Steven              Capitol College  Yes
Tayar, Gil                    WebCollage      Yes
Thompson, Rich           IBM                  Yes
Tamari, Yossi              SAP Portals      Yes
van Lydegraf, Eric         Kinzan             Yes
Wiecha, Charles           IBM                 Yes
Young, Michael            Plumtree          No

Members on Leave of Absence:
Abdelnur, Alejandro     Sun             until 26 January
Reshef, Eilon               WebCollage       until face-to-face

Prospective Members:
Rubini, Ross            Plumtree        Yes

Non-Voting Members:
Dynin, Jane                 Plumtree        No
Stanko, Joseph            Plumtree        No

32 of 36 voting members attending

Meeting started at 11:05pm EST

Correction to minutes of 7 January 2003
Rich: #174 - remove "tentative" from both lines starting with "- tentative 
resolve"
Minutes accepted with correction

Adam Nolan says his name is spelled "Nolan" not "Nolen" as posted in the 
minutes and website.
Two members moved from voting to non-voting status (see above).

#187 How does POST data reach the Producer?
         - resolved: InteractionParams.formParameters contains name value 
pairs from querystring for method=get and parsed "url-encoded" post mime 
type. Must not contain any of the interaction parameters specified in 
section 10.2 or parameters the Consumer added to the activated URL.
         - resolved: InteractionParams.uploadContexts[] holds any other 
mime types that the Consumer received.
         - no objections

#165 Still need to do namespacing on form parameters?
         -resolved: Add text that recommends html field names not use 
namespacing as it is not required.
         - resolved: Consumer only has to strip namespaces where it added 
it during URL rewriting
         - no objections

#182 Globalize address user information fields and add missing postal code
         - Note that the spec has some minor differences with JSR168
         - resolved: Stay with P3P definitions for v1
         - resolved: Eliminate deviations from P3P definitions
         - no objections

#195 user info alignment with JSR168 and P3P
         - resolved: Same as for #182
         - Send recommendation to JSR168 to also align with P3P

#188 Rename urlType to wsrp-urlType
         - resolved: Renaming approved
         - no objections

#189 Add interactionParameters for URL fragment
         - resolved: Approved add.  Call it wsrp-fragmentID
         - no objections

#197 Define new interactionParameters: wsrp-portletHandle, 
wsrp-userContextKey, wsrp-portletInstanceID
         - Generic template in primer
         - Optional for runtimeContext
         - resolved: Addition approved.
         - no objections

#196 Consumer force URL rewriting
         - resolved: Add text about how templates may be safely written 
into markup fragments for client side generation of dynamic URLs.
         - no objections

#190 Intent & scope of uniqueness of the entityInstanceID in runtimeContext
         - resolved: Add clarifying text that the intent is namespacing 
multiple instances of the portlet so it is unique for the Consumer

#192 sessionContext and cookies conflict
         - resolved: Only applies to getMarkup port type (ie is the only 
port type to support cookies).  Comment in section about bindings that 
cookies do not work across bindings
         - no objection

#193 Client enabling of cookie support
         - resolved: Primer should have statement about the importance of 
Consumers supporting cookies
         - no objections

6 open issues left
Next meeting Tuesday 14 January 2003 for 1 hour starting at 6pm German 
time/12pm EST/9am PST
Richard Jacob and Steven Smith said they will not be able to attend the 
Tuesday meeting.

Rich will put out an email tomorrow with the current issues.

Meeting ended 1:04pm EST







Steven Smith
Director of Information Services and Technology
Capitol College