OASIS Mailing List ArchivesView the OASIS mailing list archive below
or browse/search using MarkMail.

 


Help: OASIS Mailing Lists Help | MarkMail Help

wsrp-wsia message

[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]


Subject: [wsrp-wsia] Change Requests for 1/23/2003 call


If possible, it would be helpful to get some of the easier change requests 
handled before the F2F.

#1: WSRP spec / Title page / Page 1 / Line 6
        Requested by: Rich Thompson
        Old text: “WSRP_Specification-v0.89”
        Proposed text: “WSRP_Specification_v1.0”
        Reasoning: It is time to declare that we are finalizing the 1.0 
version.

#6: WSRP spec / Appendix A / Page 86
        Requested by: Subbu Allamaraju
        Old text: Role entry
        Proposed text: Delete this entry
        Reasoning: The spec no longer uses this term.

#8: WSRP spec / Appendix C / Page 89
        Requested by: Rich Thompson
        Old text:
        Proposed text: Indicate the membership of the WSIA committee at 
the time the spec becomes a committee spec in the same manner as is done 
for the WSRP committee on page 90.
        Reasoning: Such inconsistency is in bad taste. I think it is 
valuable to list everyone who was involved, but the format should also 
indicate who actually had a vote when the spec was finalized.

#9: WSRP spec / 12.22 / Page 77 / Line 3
        Requested by: Andre Kramer
        Old text: "8.1.1"
        Proposed text: "5.1.12"
        Reasoning: point to the right place

#11: WSRP spec / Title page & Appendix C
        Requested by: Alan Kropp
        Old text: "Vignette, Inc."
        Proposed text: "Vignette Corporation"

        Requested by: Yossi Tamari
        Old text: "SAP Portals"
        Proposed text: "SAP" ... for all SAP members

#12: WSRP spec; Page/Line: 17/33, 18/10, 18/18
        Requested by: Eric van Lydegraf
        Old text: ReturnAny initCookie(...
        Proposed text:ReturnAny = initCookies(...
                operations missing '=': initCookies, deregister, 
destroyPortlets
        Reasoning: Missing '=' on a few operations

#13: WSRP spec; Page/Line: 2/16, 8/17, 16/23,  74/32, 83/6,8,16,27
        Requested  by: Eric van Lydegraf
        Old text:[tabs]
        Proposed text:[space]
        Reasoning: better for reading and  printouts

#14: WSRP spec / 10.2.1.1.2 / Page 61 / Line 6
        Requested  by: Eric van  Lydegraf
        Old  text: “The  Consumer MUST process all mode and window state 
change requests and either honor  or reject them prior invoking the 
operation”
        Proposed text: “The  Consumer MUST process all mode and window 
state change requests and either honor  or reject them prior to  invoking 
the operation”
        Reasoning: Grammatical addition of "to".

#17: WSRP spec / 5.1.4 / Page 20 / Line 10 & 15
        Requested  by: Eric van Lydegraf
        Old text: “4196”
        Proposed  text: “4096”
        Reasoning: We meant this to be 4k correct? In that case it should 
be 4096

#18: WSRP spec / Heading 2  Style
        Requested by: Eric van  Lydegraf
        Old text:
        Proposed text:
        Reasoning: Inconsistent Heading indentation - should be between 
Heading 1 and Heading 3

#19: WSRP spec / Appendix C
        Requested by: Rich Thompson
        Reasoning: Membership lists should be updated to reflect current 
membership. For example, Eric VanLydegraf is missing from the WSIA list.

#21: WSRP spec / Appendix A / Page 87 / Line 2-3
        Requested by: Eric van Lydegraf
        Reasoning: User definition repeats itself - remove second 
sentence.

#22: WSRP spec / 10.4.2.2 / Page 69 / Lines 2 & 15
        Requested by: Eric  van Lydegraf
        Old  text: “HTML”
        Proposed text: either “XHTML” or “XHTML  Basic” as appropriate for 
the section 
        Reasoning: Consistency and while very close cousins these are 
distinct specifications nonetheless

#23: WSRP spec / 12.18 / Page 76 / Line: 20-23
        Requested by: Eric  van Lydegraf
        Reasoning: Indentation is not consistent with all the  others in 
the 12.x section.

#24: WSRP spec / 12.35 / Page 78 / Line 11-12
        Requested  by: Eric van  Lydegraf
        Old  text: "Ok",  "Clone", and "Fault"
        Proposed text: "ReadWrite",  "CloneBeforeWrite"  or "ReadOnly".
        Reasoning: Needs to be corrected to  match WSDL.

#26: WSRP spec (& wsdl) / 14 / Page 81 / Row 3
        Requested by: Rich Thompson
        Old text: "Security"
        Proposed text: "Interface"
        Reasoning: This is no longer a security issue (as it was when it 
was 'roles'). This row should then move down with the other interface 
rows.

Rich Thompson


[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]


Powered by eList eXpress LLC