Minutes of TC Meeting 29 March 2007

["Bill Parducci" <bill.parducci@simulalabs.com>]

Minutes of XACML TC Meeting 29 March 2007

1  Roll Call & Minutes
    Attendees
      Hal Lockhart (Co-chair)
      Bill Parducci (Co-chair, minutes)
      Rich Levinson
      Erik Rissanen
      Anne Anderson
      Seth Proctor
      David Staggs
      Abbie Barbir

      Quorum achieved (61% per Kavi)

   Approval of Minutes
    15 February TC meeting minutes
    APPROVED: UNANIMOUS CONSENT

    1 March TC meeting minutes
    APPROVED: UNANIMOUS CONSENT

    F2F 13/14 March meeting minutes (UPDATED)
    APPROVED: UNANIMOUS CONSENT


2  Administrivia

    F2F
    Hal briefly reviewed the F2F; significant progress was made in
    resolving open Issues and a number of new Issues were added.

    WS-XACML Slide Presentation
    http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/xacml/200703/msg00060.html

    InterOp Update
    Coordination continues. Current participants include: Red Hat,
    BEA, IBM, Oracle, SymLabs, Jericho Systems and  Securent.
    Drafts are being discussed for how the event will proceed.

    Use of Multiple IdPs/AAs
    Anne reviewed hte posting re: a call for Attribute usage by the
    UK JISC and US Internet2.

3  New Issues

   #? - Resource id attribute in response
        This has been logged as a new Issue.


   #70 - Must Policy[Set]Id match value
         used in a corresponding Policy[Set]IdReference?

         Anne suggested that the TC post to various places to
         find potential Use Cases and/or adoptions. If necessary
         there will be a considerable amount of work to accommodate
         this matching going forward.

         Seth offered to post an example to the list of where this
         is necessary.

  #12 - Obligations (Generalized Conclusions)

        Bill asked for Use Cases/Examples of Obligations that are
        being implemented today to help categorize Obligation traits.
        ACTION: Bill will call out to the list for Use Cases,
        Examples
        ACTION: Rich will post links to Oracle's Obligation scenarios.

     XPath
        Erik explained the namespace and XPath problem with the XPath
        functions defined in the core specification.  There is an
        xpath-expression DataType defined in the Hierarchical Resource
        Profile, but it does not make a provision for supplying the
        namespace prefix resolution information.
        DECISION: enter new issue.
        ACTION: Hal took action item for Daniel to report on whether
        there is a "standard solution" for this problem.

meeting adjourned