Re: [xacml] minutes 8 January 2009 TC meeting - UPDATED

[Anil Saldhana <Anil.Saldhana@redhat.com>]

bill parducci wrote:
> 1. Roll Call
>    Hal Lockhart (Chair)
>    Bill Parducci (Co-Chair, minutes)
>    Erik Rissanen
>    Duane DeCouteau
>    David Staggs
>    Seth Proctor
> |  Anthony Nadalin
Anil Saldhana
>
>
>   Non-voting
>    Anil Tappetla
>    Darran Rolls
>    John Tolbert
>
>    Voting Members: 7 of 9 (77%)
>
> 2. Administrivia
>    Bill reviewed the Oasis Jira setup, will post url to list.
>    Oasis' implementation of Subversion is still in beta. He will also
>    set up versions "3.0" and "3.1" and two projects: "core" and
>    "profiles" in Jira.
>
> 3. Issues
>  Advice Obligation Type
>    Hal reviewed the Advice proposal posted by Erik. The TC discussed
>    the proposal for extending Advice to Not Applicable. Hal and Bill
>    raised concerns about the processing model for determining how Not
>    Applicable Advices are determined.
>
>    The TC discussed the relationship between this Issue and the Must
>    Be Present and the Missing Attribute mechanisms currently in place.
>    Hal suggested consideration of linking these functionalities. Erik
>    offered that this does not fully address the Not Applicable
>    proposal. He will post a more detailed proposal.
>
>   Subject Inconsistencies
>     Rich reviewed the state of the Issue. He raised the concern the
>     topic has become unclear and that further clarification is needed.
>    He recommends:
>     * limiting the subject functionality in multi-profile to be only
>       one subject-category allowed to have multiple instances.
>     * consider additional future protocol semantics as multi-profile
>       pdp-pre-processor capabilities that do not impact policy model
>
> meeting adjourned.
>