[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Subject: Re: [xmlvoc] Call for voting on requirements document
Dear Garshol-san, * Lars Marius Garshol At 11:50 02/04/25 +0200, you wrote: >I vote "no". > >The reason is that I cannot in good conscience say I am happy with >this document. I feel it is far too thin. We don't yet have a very >clear idea of what it is we want to achieve, and I would like to see >us rectify that before we move on. I think more work on the >requirements document would have been a good way to work towards more >clarity. > >I agree with what Steve says about user requirements, and the lack of >those is my main reason for voting "no". The best we could do now >would IMHO be to sit down and define some use cases, and then come >back to this document and flesh it out. > >I also feel that the document as written needs a clean-up before it is >actually published to the world at large. I had a number of comments I >would have liked to make about it after the concall (although I admit >I did not say so in the concall, so nobody knew about it), but there >was no time to post them after the draft was published and before the >voting began. If I had known that voting would begin so soon I would >have acted sooner. > >This vote would have been a lot more useful if I had posted it before >everyone else had cast their votes, but time is limited, and so this >is how it came out. I am sorry about that, and I am sorry to make >trouble in this way, but I feel I can do no other. You are wonderful! I agree with you. (Though I had already voted "yes".) There must be many other requirements we don't notice. I think We had better do heuristic approach. ------------------------------------------------------------------ Motomu Naito Synergy Incubate Inc. motom@synergy.co.jp http://web.synergy.co.jp/ TEL:+81-3-5478-9901 FAX:+81-3-5478-9801 ORITA BLDG.2F, 1-30-22, Tomigaya, Shibuya-ku, Tokyo 151-0063 Japan
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Powered by eList eXpress LLC