Hi Kevin,
Thank you for your draft; I think it's good. Here is my feedback.
As you know, it seems like the word "performance" in our base document title triggered misinterpretation. When we created it, we could have (probably should have) named it 'Operational monitoring of biometrics systems'. We actually had it as an option - seen here and after that we explain why we chose the term 'Performance'. In short, one way to look at it, performance is the tip of the iceberg. Its existence is dependent on the sum of those other qualities: Reliability, Availability, Maintainability. But we realized after, that 'Operational monitoring and reporting' is the action and the common tool for tracking and controlling the specialized metrics in all four qualities.
With reference to your second piece: 'Much of OMAR has derived...'. I checked our base document to make sure.
It partially (performance-related) derives from the 19795 standards; it details the relations and the way it complements them and also some other SC37 standards and ongoing projects. It especially extends an appendix in 19795-5 regarding 'Operational system monitoring'. But it expands beyond just performance to also include reliability, availability, and maintainability which are, as noted, out of scope of those standards. So, OMAR essentially is 'Web services-based operational monitoring and reporting with focus on reliability, availability, maintainability, and performance in biometrics systems'.
Thus, as you refer to, OMAR is taking a holistic approach (for the mentioned four qualities) towards managing biometric system infrastructure. Hardware, software, or process are simply Units/Elements.
Regards, Babak
On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 7:00 AM, Kevin Mangold <kevin.mangold@nist.gov> wrote:
Submitter's message
All,
This is a DRAFT memo I put together in response to the G.17 resolution from SC 37 N5831 (text quoted below). Please review this memo and suggest any modifications during our next TC meeting.
"SC 37 welcomed the OASIS Biometrics TC report to the SC 37 Plenary contained in
document SC 37 N5776. SC 37 has reviewed this report and noted the NWIP “Best Practices
in Biometrics Performance Monitoring Programs”. SC 37 suggests that development of this
standard would benefit from the experience in ISO/IEC JTC 1 SC37/WG5 on biometric
performance testing. SC 37 would encourage and prefer development of this standard in
cooperation with SC 37. SC 37 would be happy to discuss this further with OASIS.
In addition, SC 37 suggests that OASIS considers standardization work on biometrics in the
cloud, again in cooperation with SC 37."
-- Mr. Kevin Mangold
Document Name: SC 37 N5831 -- G.17 DRAFT Response
No description provided.
Download Latest Revision
Public Download Link
Submitter: Mr. Kevin Mangold
Group: OASIS Biometrics TC
Folder: Meeting Notes
Date submitted: 2014-02-27 07:00:39
See our 62 seconds "The Big Basic Questions in Managing Biometric Applications; A BioUptime introduction [HD]" on Youtube.
Founded in 2003, Optimum Biometric Labs pioneered the cloud, big data, and 'Internet of Things' concepts for monitoring vital operational aspects of connected biometric devices and services. Today, the company is helping biometrics operators and system-owners to offer and maintain maximum quality to users while minimizing operational costs.
BioUptime® by Optimum Biometric Labs
Babak Goudarzi Pour (LinkedIn)
CEO, Optimum Biometric Labs
Swedish (SIS) technical expert to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC37 - Biometrics
Chairman, Swedish National Biometric Association
......................................................................................
Phone (USA): +1 (714) 609-4815
Skype: random_precision
USA visiting office
Visit our websites:
www.OptimumBiometrics.com
www.BioUptime.com
USA visiting office
263 Lockford, Irvine, CA 92602, USA
Main Office
Campus Gräsvik 5, SE-371 75 Karlskrona, Sweden
Campus Gräsvik 5, SE-371 75 Karlskrona, Sweden
www.OptimumBiometrics.com
www.BioUptime.com
A co-founding member of Swedish National Biometric Association:
And
On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 7:00 AM, Kevin Mangold <kevin.mangold@nist.gov> wrote:
Submitter's message
All,
This is a DRAFT memo I put together in response to the G.17 resolution from SC 37 N5831 (text quoted below). Please review this memo and suggest any modifications during our next TC meeting.
"SC 37 welcomed the OASIS Biometrics TC report to the SC 37 Plenary contained in
document SC 37 N5776. SC 37 has reviewed this report and noted the NWIP “Best Practices
in Biometrics Performance Monitoring Programs”. SC 37 suggests that development of this
standard would benefit from the experience in ISO/IEC JTC 1 SC37/WG5 on biometric
performance testing. SC 37 would encourage and prefer development of this standard in
cooperation with SC 37. SC 37 would be happy to discuss this further with OASIS.
In addition, SC 37 suggests that OASIS considers standardization work on biometrics in the
cloud, again in cooperation with SC 37."
-- Mr. Kevin Mangold
Document Name: SC 37 N5831 -- G.17 DRAFT Response
No description provided.
Download Latest Revision
Public Download Link
Submitter: Mr. Kevin Mangold
Group: OASIS Biometrics TC
Folder: Meeting Notes
Date submitted: 2014-02-27 07:00:39
See our 62 seconds "The Big Basic Questions in Managing Biometric Applications; A BioUptime introduction [HD]" on Youtube.
Founded in 2003, Optimum Biometric Labs pioneered the cloud, big data, and 'Internet of Things' concepts for monitoring vital operational aspects of connected biometric devices and services. Today, the company is helping biometrics operators and system-owners to offer and maintain maximum quality to users while minimizing operational costs.
BioUptime® by Optimum Biometric Labs
Babak Goudarzi Pour (LinkedIn)
CEO, Optimum Biometric Labs
Swedish (SIS) technical expert to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC37 - Biometrics
Chairman, Swedish National Biometric Association
......................................................................................
Phone (USA): +1 (714) 609-4815
Skype: random_precision
USA visiting office
Visit our websites:
www.OptimumBiometrics.com
www.BioUptime.com
USA visiting office
263 Lockford, Irvine, CA 92602, USA
Main Office
Campus Gräsvik 5, SE-371 75 Karlskrona, Sweden
Campus Gräsvik 5, SE-371 75 Karlskrona, Sweden
www.OptimumBiometrics.com
www.BioUptime.com
A co-founding member of Swedish National Biometric Association:
And
On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 7:00 AM, Kevin Mangold <kevin.mangold@nist.gov> wrote:
Submitter's message
All,
This is a DRAFT memo I put together in response to the G.17 resolution from SC 37 N5831 (text quoted below). Please review this memo and suggest any modifications during our next TC meeting.
"SC 37 welcomed the OASIS Biometrics TC report to the SC 37 Plenary contained in
document SC 37 N5776. SC 37 has reviewed this report and noted the NWIP “Best Practices
in Biometrics Performance Monitoring Programs”. SC 37 suggests that development of this
standard would benefit from the experience in ISO/IEC JTC 1 SC37/WG5 on biometric
performance testing. SC 37 would encourage and prefer development of this standard in
cooperation with SC 37. SC 37 would be happy to discuss this further with OASIS.
In addition, SC 37 suggests that OASIS considers standardization work on biometrics in the
cloud, again in cooperation with SC 37."
-- Mr. Kevin Mangold
Document Name: SC 37 N5831 -- G.17 DRAFT Response
No description provided.
Download Latest Revision
Public Download Link
Submitter: Mr. Kevin Mangold
Group: OASIS Biometrics TC
Folder: Meeting Notes
Date submitted: 2014-02-27 07:00:39
See our 62 seconds "The Big Basic Questions in Managing Biometric Applications; A BioUptime introduction [HD]" on Youtube.
Founded in 2003, Optimum Biometric Labs pioneered the cloud, big data, and 'Internet of Things' concepts for monitoring vital operational aspects of connected biometric devices and services. Today, the company is helping biometrics operators and system-owners to offer and maintain maximum quality to users while minimizing operational costs.
BioUptime® by Optimum Biometric Labs
Babak Goudarzi Pour (LinkedIn)
CEO, Optimum Biometric Labs
Swedish (SIS) technical expert to ISO/IEC JTC1/SC37 - Biometrics
Chairman, Swedish National Biometric Association
......................................................................................
Phone (USA): +1 (714) 609-4815
Skype: random_precision
USA visiting office
Visit our websites:
www.OptimumBiometrics.com
www.BioUptime.com
USA visiting office
263 Lockford, Irvine, CA 92602, USA
Main Office
Campus Gräsvik 5, SE-371 75 Karlskrona, Sweden
Campus Gräsvik 5, SE-371 75 Karlskrona, Sweden
www.OptimumBiometrics.com
www.BioUptime.com
A co-founding member of Swedish National Biometric Association:
And