[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Re: [bpel4people-editors] Forward Progress on BP-16
Dear BPEL4People Editing team, I collected a couple of review comments
listed below - we may walk through in one of the next editor's calls.
Section 3.2.
line 516 - "they can be used" would be sufficient - no MAY needed
Section 4.+5.
(edited by DK) no comments
Section 6.
line 1811 (void response) - this is normatively addressed in
ws-humantask-api.wsdl - no issue required
line 1826 - broken reference
line 1845 - dup of line 1808
line 1935 - add "A WS-HT processor MUST support the XPath functions listed
below"?
Section 7.
line 1993 - "WS-HumanTask Processor implementation" - drop "implementation"
line 2001 - "The parent application MUST react ..." - not sure if we need
this - it is alread mandated by WS-Coordination
line 2014 (same on line 2019 and line 2028) - "Response message SHOULD NOT
..." - revert to original sentence (this is a one-way operation - there is
never a response)
line 2017 (same on line 2033) - >>>NEW ISSUE<<< - scenario 3 - the parent
application must be a conformance target (!) as it has to send the "exit"
protocol message - in line 2033, they are called "Human task aware
requesting applications" - in line 2301, "the caller" is used
line 2048 and line 2053 (attachments) - MAY seems ok as the attachment
concept as a whole is optional
line 2057 and line 2060 - change "No attachments MUST be returned." to "
Attachments MUST NOT be returned."
line 2063 - drop "No attachments MUST be returned.."
line 2087 and line 2095 - again, the absence of a response is already
covered by the normative one-way interface of protocol operations, so these
two sentences can be reverted to their original wording
line 2114 - replace MAY by MUST,
line 2143 - revert "WS-HumanTask Definition" to "WS-HumanTask" - the
context is completely independent of a task definition
line 2197 - (policy assertion) replace MAY by SHOULD
Section 8.
line 2301 - "the caller" (conformance target) - see issue above
line 2335 - replace ")will be used" by "is used" (always use present tense)
line 2408 - add normative language to the SOAP binding section
line 2470 - replace "caller" by "WS-HumanTask Processor"
Kind Regards
Dieter König
Senior Technical Staff Member, WebSphere Process Server Architect
IBM Software Group, Application and Integration Middleware Software
WSS Business Process Solutions
Phone: +49-7031-16-3426 IBM Deutschland (Embedded
image moved
to file:
pic09875.gif)
E-Mail: dieterkoenig@de.ibm.com Schönaicher Str. 220
71032 Böblingen
Germany
IBM Deutschland
Research &
Development
GmbH /
Vorsitzender des
Aufsichtsrats:
Martin Jetter
Geschäftsführung:
Erich Baier
Sitz der
Gesellschaft:
Böblingen /
Registergericht:
Amtsgericht
Stuttgart, HRB
243294
From: "Luc Clement" <luc.clement@activevos.com>
To: <bpel4people-editors@lists.oasis-open.org>
Date: 05.12.2008 02:15
Subject: [bpel4people-editors] Forward Progress on BP-16
Folks,
Unfortunately, we weren’t able to make progress on the HT review this week.
Ivana, Dieter and I discussed when we met briefly on Wednesday that we need
to close our review of HT by Wed 10 and the review of the B4P updates by
Wed 17. This would permit the TC to approve our BP-16 proposal, and
subsequently release CD-02 early in the new year.
To this end we ask that all editors provide input on the HT updates
starting from 3.2 (to the end) no later than 10 Dec.
Ralf has not only completed his updates to B4P but mine also J. Sections 1
through 6 have been completed, and Ravi now has the pen. Given this
progress and on the assumption that Ravi will be completed shortly, I ask
that all input on BP-16 updates to B4P be submitted by the 17th.
If there are any issues that need to be discussed, we can do so on the
meetings of the 10th and 17th.
Let’s get this done before Xmas. I trust that everyone is on board with
this.
Luc’
Luc Clément
Active Endpoints, Inc
+1.978.793.2162 | luc.clement@activevos.com
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
