[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Subject: RE: [bt-spec] BTP Issue 99 : PREPARE_INFERIORS andFAULT(InvalidInferior)
|
Mark and I have
batted this one back and forth several times, and I believe we now have some
common base with a clear alternative on a detail, so let's take it to a
vote.
I tried proposing a
two-way choice on issue 60, but Bill merged it. I'd really like to suggest we
offer both options on this, as it saves going round twice. I'm asking that
votes in favour should distinguish A or B. And to make things simple (and show
how fair minded I am, since I prefer B :-), a Yes vote that doesn't distinguish
counts as Yes(A). But Bill calls the votes.
Proposed
solution:
In the description
of CANCEL_INFERIORS add:
If one or more of
the "inferior-identifier"s in the "inferior-list" is unknown (does not
correspond to an enrolled Inferior), a FAULT(Invalid-inferior) shall be
returned. It is an implementation option whether CANCEL is sent to any of the
Inferiors that are validly idenitfied in the
"inferiors-list".
In the description
of CONFIRM_INFERIORS add:
If one or more of
the "inferior-identifier"s in the "inferior-list" is unknown (does not
correspond to an enrolled Inferior), a FAULT(Invalid-inferior) shall be
returned. The Decider shall not make a confirm decision and shall not send
CONFIRM to any Inferior.
In the
description of PREPARE_INFERIORS add:
CHOICE
A:
If one or more of the "inferior-identifier"s in the
"inferior-list" is unknown (does not correspond to an enrolled Inferior), a
FAULT(Invalid-inferior) shall be returned. The Decider shall not send PREPARE to
any Inferior.
CHOICE
B: If one or more of the "inferior-identifier"s in the
"inferior-list" is unknown (does not correspond to an enrolled Inferior), a
FAULT(Invalid-inferior) shall be returned. It is an implementation option
whether PREPARE is sent to any of the Inferiors that are validly idenitfied in
the "inferiors-list".
Peter |
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Powered by eList eXpress LLC