[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Subject: RE: [business-transaction] Model section vote closed April 11(tommorrow)!
Bill, Snipping where I've no further comment: > Reassert Issue 25 until conformance is cleared up (and it's almost there) Shall we make this a dependent issue ? - I merged the existing conformance issues (26 and 87) by making 26 depend on 87 (the direction was arbitrary), to better reflect how many outstanding issues there were. > Reassert Issue 66 until interaction and state diagrams for > termination protocol are > as clear as the rest. Figure 9 is an interaction diagram, and figures 10, 11 and 13 state diagrams, for the whole lifecycle, so they do include the termination. We don't have an interaction one showing cancels though, or a cohesion's mixed outcome. Sanjay: do you want to do some more ? I/Tony can do some. > DETAILS:: > > Issue 24: I'm now happy (mostly) with the model exposition and > section. It > still needs more interaction diagrams; the state diagrams are > very useful. A > state diagram for the hazard and termination sections would be useful. trouble with interaction diagrams is knowing when to stop :-) OSI TP had something like 200, (i.e. near the size of our entire document). > Issue 27: Well, Draft 0.9 is STILL opaque and difficult to read and to > understand (and will be forever :-) ). Draft 0.9.5 is NOT. > I'd like to thank > Peter as editor and the rest of the group for the focus on readability and > understandability; this really has come quite close to my > goal...of course, > "centre" still isn't spelled right! thank you. Document's not 100% consistent on -ise and -ize actually. (How do people from Noo Joisy spell "wise" and "otherwise" ?) :-) > Issue 73: I couldn't find text that satisfied this issue from > Pyounguk. Hope > he's happy. Spec doesn't actually compare itself with ACID, I think (ACID does not appear to be in it at all)
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Powered by eList eXpress LLC