docbook-tc message

Subject: [docbook-tc] FW: DOCBOOK: XML Character Entities Version 0.2

From: Michael Smith <smith@xml-doc.org>
To: Greg Murray <gpm2a@neon.mail.virginia.edu>
Date: Tue, 02 Apr 2002 01:02:47 -0600

Hi Greg,

I went ahead and filed an RFE for about the possible errors you found
in the descriptions in the XML character entity files.

  http://sourceforge.net/tracker/index.php?func=detail&aid=538187&group_id=21935&atid=384107

And I'm cc'ing the DocBook TC mailing list on this.

Regards,

  --Mike Smith

--- Begin Message ---

From: Greg Murray <gpm2a@neon.mail.virginia.edu>
To: docbook@lists.oasis-open.org
Date: Mon, 01 Apr 2002 12:49:47 -0500 (EST)

There are a handful of descriptions in the DocBook entity files that
appear to be incorrect, and are therefore a bit confusing.

For the cdot entity (iso-lat2.ent)
  <!ENTITY cdot  "&#x010B;"> <!-- DOT OPERATOR -->
the correct description would be
  <!ENTITY cdot  "&#x010B;"> <!-- LATIN SMALL LETTER C WITH DOT ABOVE -->

In iso-num.ent, the description for
  <!ENTITY ast "&#x002A;"> <!-- ASTERISK OPERATOR -->
should probably be simply "ASTERISK", for consistency with other
characters that accompany it in the entity set, such as "NUMBER SIGN",
"PERCENT SIGN", "COMMERCIAL AT", and so forth. "ASTERISK OPERATOR" is a
different Unicode character, not the regular asterisk referred to by
x002A.

Also in iso-num.ent, the descriptions for the following
  <!ENTITY larr   "&#x2190;"> <!-- LEFTWARDS DOUBLE ARROW -->
  <!ENTITY rarr   "&#x2192;"> <!-- RIGHTWARDS DOUBLE ARROW -->
should say simply "ARROW", not "DOUBLE ARROW".

Since these suggestions only pertain to the descriptions, not the
character mapping themselves, they are, of course, very minor.
Nevertheless I wanted to bring these matters to your attention, in the
event that you consider them worth fixing.

Thank you for maintaining the closest thing we have to a definitive,
authoritative, standard set of ISO 8879 entity files for use with XML.

Greg Murray


===================================
Greg Murray
XML/Text Programmer
Digital Library Production Services
University of Virginia Library
murray@virginia.edu  (434) 924-6732
===================================

--- End Message ---



-- 
Michael Smith, Tokyo, Japan    http://sideshowbarker.net
&#x30DE;&#x30A4;&#x30AF;

The mysteries of human nature
surpass the "mysteries of redemption,"
for the infinite we only suppose,
while we see the finite.

  --Emily Dickinson (*251)     http://www.logopoeia.com/ed/