OASIS Mailing List ArchivesView the OASIS mailing list archive below
or browse/search using MarkMail.

 


Help: OASIS Mailing Lists Help | MarkMail Help

dss message

[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]


Subject: wd-42 errors and typos


Editors ...

Just in case these haven't been corrected already, here are some things to
correct/review. Most are typos, some are semantic, some are suggested
changes, and a few might be issues (i.e. 22, 25, 35, 39, 40).

1) line 146: remove s from applications

2) line 200: change itself to themselves

3) line 219: "The signing and verifying protocols can be used to create and
verify XML timestamps;"

Should be changed to "The signing and verifying protocols can be used to
create and verify both XML and binary timestamps;"

4) line 220: make Requester Identity one word i.e. RequesterIdentity 

5) line 289: change "our" to "the"

6) line 290: change "we will explain" to "it is explained"

7) line 331: "is not parseable XML data," should be changed to "is not
parseable XML data, after appropriate decoding,"

8) line 339: capitalize xml

9) line 343: change "it contains" to "it may contain" due to optionality

10) line 351: capitalize xml

11) line 462: capitalize xml

12) line 596: remove "is suggest"

13) line 599: remove "some"

14) line 606: change "with in" to "within"

15) line 704: remove "for"

16) line 712: change "constituents" to "syntax"

17) line 808: add "a" in front of "pointer"

18) line 841: change "Transforms are applied as a server implementation MAY
choose to increase robustness of the Signatures created." to
"Transforms can be applied by a server implementation which MAY choose to
increase the robustness of the Signatures created."

19) line 844-845: change "data binary" to "binary data"

20) line 1024: change "timestamp" to "timestamps"

21) line 1025: change "defines procedures for handling timestamps against
the document being signed" to
"defines procedures for generating timestamps over the content which is
about to be signed"

22) line 1070: "The present document does not establish a unique solution.
It is a matter of server policy to decide how to incorporate signature
timestamps in the XML signatures rendered to its clients"

This phrase should either be reworded or removed as it will create
inter-operability anomalies across core implementations.

23) line 1207: change "included" to "include"

24) line 1216: change XMLDSig to XMLSig

25) line 1223-1226: "In the case of a non-XML input document, or when these
child elements are omitted, then the server places the signature in the
input document in accordance with procedures defined in a profile or as part
of the server policy."

I believe we should reject non-XML Documents as default core processing when
Enveloped signatures are requested.

26) line 1274: remove "that"

27) line 1298: replace "Base64XML is indicated" with "Base64XML or
EscapedXML may be required"

28) line 1316: change "since they are aspects of" to "they need to be
specified by"

29) line 1322: change "on" to "of"

30) line 1324-1325: have no idea what this is supposed to mean ???

31) line 1341: "worth according to its policy for generating" to
"appropriate as per its policy and then generates"

32) line 1364: same change as 31)

33) line 1488-1489: fix up "without attributes Attribute namespace
inheritance" ???

34) line 1490: change "there can appear problems" to "problems might arise"

35) line 1515-1517: "Upon receiving this result code, the client SHOULD NOT
assume any particular relationship between the signature and the input
document(s).  To check such a relationship, the client would have to verify
or inspect the signatures individually."

Can this not be omitted as there is only one InputDocument in
Multi-signature scenarios ?

36) line 1526: change "timestamp" to "timestamps"

37) line 1530: change "For definition" to "For a definition"

38) in line 1626 and 1628: change XMLDSIG to XMLSig

39) line 1656: "instead of the current time" implies that the DSS
implementation always uses the current time by default. What if
"SigningTime" is present in the signature ? This optional input element
needs to be re-written to reflect questions fielded from the public review.

40) line 1747: a note should be made that qualifies the 3rd party's ability
to attest to the SigningTime (i.e. only content Timestamps applied before
signature creation should result in the ThirdPartyTimestamp boolean being
turned on, since a signature Timestamp may be applied months after
SigningTime.)

41) line 1834: change "timestamp" to "timestamps"

42) line 1851: "XML timestamps can be produced and verified using the
timestamping profile of the DSS core protocols [XML-TSP]."

This sentence implies that they cannot be produced by the core.

43) line 1872: refers to section 5.1.3 which does not exist ???

44) line 1885: change "appropriated" to "appropriate"

    Didn't really check the rest ...

Cheers,
Ed























[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]