Re: SV: [ebcore] Groups - cppa3-specification uploaded

I just want to add that in the Norwegian health sector we are about to start using the packaging from CPP so that a Doctor sending a message to another Doctor somewhere in Norway can check beforehand to find out which versions of an XML Document the intended recipient understands and create the best version that the recipient can receive.

Today such information is unavailable so the sender defaults to the oldest version the sender can create.

------------------------------------
Med vennlig hilsen

Sigbjørn Berntzen

Integrasjonsspesialist

Kontor for Integrasjon // IT Felleskomponenter

NAV IT // Arbeids- og velferdsdirektoratet

(: 21 07 07 96 // 93 49 49 01
*: sigbjorn.berntzen@nav.no

P Please consider the environment before printing this email

Fra: Pim van der Eijk [mailto:pvde@sonnenglanz.net]
Sendt: 3. mai 2017 10:09
Til: Yngve Pettersen; ebcore-comment@lists.oasis-open.org
Kopi: =?UTF-8?Q?Sigbj=c3=b8rn_Berntzen_=28sigbjorn.berntzen@
Emne: Re: [ebcore] Groups - cppa3-specification uploaded

Hi Yngve,

Many thanks for your email and it's not too late at all, perfect timing instead.

I will reply to your points later this week. Please let me know if it's OK if I forward your email to the public ebcore tc or comment list?

Kind Regards,

Pim

On 03-05-17 08:55, Yngve Pettersen wrote:

Hi Pim!

Sorry for late feedback, and hope it's not too late J

Regarding the CPPA3, I have not be able to read the spec in detail but as far I can see there are some good things.

Ithink the new ServiceSpecification is fine. It's very nice to be able to build up the complete process in the CPP or CPA and show which message following the others. CPPA2 was difficult to follow with CanSend/CanReceive.

It's also good to see that we can state the counterpart role. This will really help.

But…

Why changing the Packaging? In CPPA2 you could explain in detail how a file should be packed, encrypted and zipped, and also the which version of message that was used. This is a large step backwards I think.

And…why change almost all tags? It's will be more difficult to acquire CPPA3 if you are familiar with CPPA2 because of the new structure, look complete new and strange for me.

I'm also concerned about the security and how we state the certificate details. But as I said, I have not read this spec in detail and had not time to compare with CPPA2 on this issue so it might be ok.

Med vennlig hilsen / Best regards

Yngve Pettersen

Seniorrådgiver / Senior adviser

Mobile (+47) 950 85 477

Havnelageret

Langkaia 1

NO-0150 OSLO

Tel: (+47) 22 42 13 80

Fax: (+47) 22 42 26 40

www.edisys.no

Edisys Consulting AS harNorges ledende fagmiljø innen elektronisk samhandling og kan bidra til økt lønnsomhet gjennom forenkling og automatisering av forretningsprosesser.

Vi deltar også i samarbeidetOverhuset (www.overhuset.no) som samler Norges skarpeste konsulentmiljøer i IT-bransjen i et felles nettverk, og under et felles varemerke.

P Please consider the environment before printing this email

From: Pim van der Eijk [mailto:pvde@sonnenglanz.net]
Sent: 3. april 2017 08.27
To: Yngve Pettersen <yngve.pettersen@edisys.no>
Subject: Re: [ebcore] Groups - cppa3-specification uploaded

Hi Yngve,

Great, you can download all documents from https://www.oasis-open.org/committees/documents.php?wg_abbrev=ebcore&show_descriptions=yes.

Any comments you can post formally via https://www.oasis-open.org/committees/comments/index.php?wg_abbrev=ebcore or informally to me directly.

Best regards.

Pim

On 03-04-17 08:22, Yngve Pettersen wrote:

Hi Pim!

How are you?

I'm always interested in CPP and CPA, hehe.. J

FYI, at the moment I'm out of the Norwegian Directorate of eHealth…for some time since my contract was out in the end of 2016.

But I will look at it and give you my feedback.

Med vennlig hilsen / Best regards

Yngve Pettersen

Seniorrådgiver / Senior adviser

Mobile (+47) 950 85 477

Havnelageret

Langkaia 1

NO-0150 OSLO

Tel: (+47) 22 42 13 80

Fax: (+47) 22 42 26 40

www.edisys.no

Edisys Consulting AS harNorges ledende fagmiljø innen elektronisk samhandling og kan bidra til økt lønnsomhet gjennom forenkling og automatisering av forretningsprosesser.

Vi deltar også i samarbeidetOverhuset (www.overhuset.no) som samler Norges skarpeste konsulentmiljøer i IT-bransjen i et felles nettverk, og under et felles varemerke.

P Please consider the environment before printing this email

From: Pim van der Eijk [mailto:pvde@sonnenglanz.net]
Sent: 2. april 2017 15.48
To: Yngve Pettersen <yngve.pettersen@edisys.no>
Subject: Fwd: [ebcore] Groups - cppa3-specification uploaded

Hi Yngve,

Not sure if your email address still works, and/or you are still interested in CPA. We talked/emailed about it in the past.

After many years, I'm trying to finalize a CPPA3 that has all the modernization and extensions needed for current protocols.

If you have time to review it and provide some feedback, that would be much appreciated.

Kind Regards,

Pim

-------- Forwarded Message --------

Subject:

[ebcore] Groups - cppa3-specification uploaded

Date:

Sun, 2 Apr 2017 05:08:22 -0700 (PDT)

From:

Pim van der Eijk <pvde@sonnenglanz.net>

To:

ebcore@lists.oasis-open.org

Submitter's message
Schema #15 (2017-03-27) and #16 (2017-04-02):
- New chapter 2.3.4 on schema extensibility.
- Description of IPv4 and IPv6 support features and related constraints in unification in new section 3.4.16.
- “Certification Authority”, naming consistency.
- “Content Coding” support for HTTP.
- “HTTP Version” support for HTTP.
- Editorial.
- Fixed some missing coverage of elements in 3.4.2.
- Added bibliographic entries for FTP and SMTP RFCs and MTOM and XOP W3C Recommendations.
-- Mr. Pim van der Eijk

Document Name: cppa3-specification

Description
Specification (in ODF) of the CPPA3 schema and unification method. Also
includes some XML samples.
Download Latest Revision
Public Download Link

Submitter: Mr. Pim van der Eijk
Group: OASIS ebXML Core (ebCore) TC
Folder: Contributions
Date submitted: 2017-04-02 05:07:56
Revision: 5

ebcore-comment message