Subject: Re: [ebcore-comment] ebCore Agreement Update Specification Version 1.0
Many thanks to you for reviewing this specification. We will process your comments and prepare an updated version.
I would like to specifically comment on TAB-1346.
The W3C recommendation provides an XML Schema that we wanted to link to. However, that schema file has several known issues, as documented at https://www.w3.org/2008/xmlsec/errata/xmldsig-core-11-errata.html. So any schema that imports this W3C schema is invalid.
When creating the AU schema I manually fixed the referenced schema. However, the result is an edited version of a W3C copyright file. It would be preferable if W3C would publish a version of the schema file that incorporates those fixes, which this OASIS schema could then simply reference. We have been in touch with the W3C team but have not heard back from them yet.
We would appreciate your on how to proceed. Some options are:
(1) We could publish a fixed version as part of the OASIS ebCore AU package.
(2) We could add a note to users that they need to create such a fixed version themselves and reference it from their downloaded copy of the file, if they want to use the schema for purposes like validation.
(3) continue to engage with W3C and wait until they fix the schema. However, that would delay further progress in ebCore.
Copying the ebCore TC so they are aware.
On 10-12-15 01:00, Patrick Durusau wrote:
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 Greetings! Members of the Technical Advisory Board endeavor to comment on all 30 day public review drafts. Comments on: ebCore Agreement Update Specification Version 1.0 are attached. It isn't necessary to acknowledge each comment separately. A single email acknowledging this email will be sufficient. If the TC chooses to ?defer? resolution of an issue to a later version, please choose Defer Issue under Available Workflow Actions (after opening the issue). When the TC has acted on these issues, I would appreciate a pointer to the TCs resolution as the TAB is tracking the resolution of comments from TAB members. Hope everyone is having a great week! Patrick - -- Patrick Durusau firstname.lastname@example.org Technical Advisory Board, OASIS (TAB) OpenDocument Format TC (OASIS), Project Editor ISO/IEC 26300 Co-Editor 13250-5 (Topic Maps) Another Word For It (blog): http://tm.durusau.net Homepage: http://www.durusau.net Twitter: patrickDurusau -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v1 iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJWaMCWAAoJEFPGsgi3MgycmD0QAKdy8efaSKp7l4thXbajo8lE WTu0be5Wa0ncvpe07rYX6bQO3Xtg0oDec61GS46MFGfB7QGvUsLFGP2ifsvem1gR nOeaM/jeIVlPknQPSWdYBGeWEAv2xcqHmPB+UP5mPuzzE0Q2MYj2tw2VdqK6T6mU CxKPXMRykMm14VTCd/3zlkpbo/SPHgiEVboX2FxXOiWSJ3G9E5ukogA37Zvsx493 9F9aKmPBzgG4WW+OgLvV2I7nLEML9d6D8Ac7opci5lmrXr5cuxCV+s1ncYJtETPt AX/4qZfXBK/utUYlhMSkHLm3SGdvvfjRHdXi9weTLxLpr8Jna0RcWeNaLzpH26cW 8U+f8uzp2fXX6Fmm0MIPWgN0xosY9y2+S0sYHVKKpaZ8x6G+K+YZ1Tle7/eL1riD 0B0nqc18qMmNO6I6okHwDPwMwH0aOSN2unnxN/XZ2iPFd7K3kYgoJAxmdR+vFY3m /UNF4A9tPEn/qOVfEh7iloL3Zjeuc6Gis5DIwBSvnrLfzwudtFFgTPE/V+ustT9m SOnqrecsWWQ3j1VGqDTk+e+B099HbdgfZx+pmbyJB1IbZlq7/3DLKThf/ejf9OFi PY1hMrj+VuxoIak7kAx2XtltfMnGowvw5t7xx/6WgtWeJn7GD/+EXg/9JJ8QzdCG NualupgI7xaVofGGYen7 =H1he -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----