[ebxml-cppa] Arvola's comments on version 1.01

[Tony Weida <rweida@hotmail.com>]

Arvola,

Regarding two comments you included for version 1.01 (the version I
distributed to the list, with changes highlighted):

1. You commented about lines 339-343: "It was agreed in the joint MSG-CPPA
meeting in October that the 1.1 CPP/A spec will not address the requirements
for interacting with intermediaries."

I believe the identified text is broadly informational in nature and doesn't
conflict with your comment, so I'd be inclined to remove that comment from
version 1.02.  Okay?

2. You commented on the confidentiality attribute, lines 1503-1504) as
follows: "I think the last part of the sentence "and delivered, encrypted,
to the application" should be struck out. The encryption might have happened
before the ebXML message is packaged and signed. The middleware on the
receiver side probably should pass the decrypted payload to the destination
application."

In response, I commented: "I thought the intent of this attribute was to
specify confidential delivery between applications, and thus the sentence
should remain intact."  Is that agreeable, or shall I record this as an
issue?

Regards,
Tony