Re: [ebxml-msg] Groups - ebXML Messaging TC weekly call added

[Sander Fieten <sander@fieten-it.com>]

I think there're now two open questions from our last discussions:

1) Should the splitting/joining feature be part of the spec itself or in a
separate document?
I've no opinion on whether to include this or not. As I also made a remark
on one of the calls I think the layer in the stack is not completely logical
to me. This is caused by the fact that the input for splitting is the MIME
multi part message, but without the security and RM. I expect that the MIME
multi part is normally created in the lowest layer (transport). So after
applying security and RM. Implying that splitting would come after security
and RM. 
Using splitting requires constructing the MIME multi part before applying
security and RM, so "circumventing" the security and RM layer. Then the
message is split and processed by security, RM and transport (where a new
MIME multi part may be constructed).

2) Do we want to include the "recovery feature" using selective pulling?
If I interpreted the Core spec right there's already a possibility for
recovering. In section 8.3.3 (about Two-way Sync) there's a reference to
section 8.3.2 (One-way Pull) on the dependencies/requirements. In this
section it is stated: "In addition, if the MEP request is also under
At-Most-Once reliability contract, and if it has been delivered and
responded to by the Responder RMP, then if a duplicate of the MEP request is
received later, a duplicate of the same response that has been returned for
the initial request MUST be returned for the duplicate request."
This seems to apply that by resending the original request you can recover
from the failed response.

Another question is when we want to finish part 2?

Regards
Sander

On 25-05-10 14:00, "ian.c.jones@bt.com" <ian.c.jones@bt.com> wrote:

> Team,
> 
>     reminder Pim has posted updates to the V3 spec.
> 
> Ian

 -- Ian Jones


ebXML Messaging TC weekly call  has been added by Ian
> Jones

Date:  Wednesday, 26 May 2010
Time:  11:30am - 01:00pm PT

Event
> Description:
ebXML Messaging TC weekly call
> 
> Tel: +1-218-486-8700
> Pass code 120905

Agenda:
1. Role
> 2. Review of this weeks updates
> Restart (AS2) 
> Pulling specific document
> 3. AS4 - Updates 
> 4. A.O.B 

Minutes:


View event
> details:
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/ebxml-msg/event.php?even
> t_id=27720

PLEASE NOTE:  If the above link does not work for you, your
> email
application may be breaking the link into two pieces.  You may be able
> to
copy and paste the entire link address into the address field of your
> web
browser.