Re: [egov-ms] Groups - Making the transition from IPv4 to IPv6 -removing the barriers (IPv6_Guidance Doc_v1.0.pdf) uploaded

[Tony Rutkowski <tony@yaanatech.com>]

Hi John,

> The document named Making the transition from IPv4 to IPv6 - removing the
> barriers (IPv6_Guidance Doc_v1.0.pdf) has been submitted by Mr. John
> Borras* to the OASIS eGovernment Member Section document repository.
>
>    
I urge the committee/OASIS to reconsider the release of
this document.  It both significantly overstates the importance
of a transition as well as fails completely to account for the
emergence of LISP over the next 2-3 years.  That is the
important transition, not IPv4 to IPv6.

There have also been an increasing number of studies and
articles noting the reality of the transition not occurring in the
network infrastructure, and its increasing irrelevance.  One
would expect an OASIS report to minimally state more than
one perspective.

I realize that diverse government/intergovernmental reports
and IPv6 promotional materials exist - as they have for the
past 15 years - but that's what they are, marketing material
that doesn't reflect reality.

best,
tony