Re: HAVE JIRA issues

["Darrell O'Donnell" <darrell.odonnell@continuumloop.com>]

From our session this morning - I will be uploading it momentarily as well.

Robert - (CC'ed as not formally registered as part of SC) - you'll see some solid feedback in here on approach. One item of note - I will be doing a review on #51 as I think some of these specifications should be referenced so I am looking at which ones we need and where we can add a sentence or two to do so. I will have that review done tonight.

cheers,

Darrell

Darrell O'Donnell, P.Eng.

darrell.odonnell@continuumloop.com

On Wed, Aug 2, 2017 at 9:47 PM, Elysa Jones <elysajones@yahoo.com> wrote:

WOW, great stuff Rex!  We should be able to make great progress with your input here and let you sleep in a bit in the morning.  I trust Robert will be able to make the document changes from here.

 

I’m reviewing/updating the SOU and working the 1.0.  I’ll be on the call tomorrow and may have my bit ready as well.

 

From: rexbroo [mailto:rexb@starbourne.com]
Sent: Wednesday, August 2, 2017 8:22 PM
To: O'Connor, Robert <Robert.O'Connor@iem.com>; Darrell O'Donnell <darrell.odonnell@continuumloop.com>; Elysa Jones <elysajones@yahoo.com>
Subject: Re: HAVE JIRA issues

 

This took me 4.5 hrs total, but it should cut down tomorrow's work. I definitely do not volunteer to do this. The data dictionary was my contribution.

40-Add conformance clause in Section 5 of spec doc per Darrell's suggestion. follow example of EDXL-RM http://docs.oasis-open.org/emergency/edxl-rm/v1.0/os/EDXL-RM-v1.0-OS.doc

41-This should be marked resolved. It has been handled by the addition of the conventional data dictionary.

42-Move EDXL-DE to Non Normative References and make 'Non Normative References' a heading: e.g.1.3 Non Normative References

43-Mark as resolved, the reference in the current draft spec doc is correct

44-Mark as resolved. It has been handled in the data dictionary.

45-Appendix A should be removed as it has been superseded by the data dictionary. Mark as resolved.

46-I vote to reply "Declined"

47-Suggest following example Conformance Section of EDXL-RM http://docs.oasis-open.org/emergency/edxl-rm/v1.0/os/EDXL-RM-v1.0-OS.doc since the data dictionary now contains requirements and if we get this back from the Public Review I would decline to go into detail about requirements or else we'll be at this when hell freezes over.

48-Mark as resolved due to addition of conventional data dictionary.

49-I vote to decline with comment to commenter that we will decline in future too, if this is returned to us unless commenter cares to be specific about exactly what passages (Line numbers) are referred to in Section 3.5 that references Section 3.3 as if it is normative. In that case, I'd change the passage in Section 3.5 whatever it is.

50-Drop the unused references while moving EDXL-DE to Non Normative References.

51-Drop the unused references.

52-Use the recommended superseding references.

53-Use the recommended current citation

54-Use the recommended current citation

55-Use the recommended current citation

56-Be sure to delete the unused references first, then: Use the correct styling, but follow the tabular format already in use since the format that follows applies only to typestyle, not tabular format http://docs.oasis-open.org/TChandbook/Reference/WPQualityChecklist.html

EXAMPLE CITATION CONSTRUCTION:

[CITATION-LABEL]
Work Product title (italicized). Approval date (DD Month YYYY). Stage Identifier and Revision Number (e.g., Committee Specification Draft 01). Principal URI (version-specific URI, e.g., including the filename component with stage and revision: /somespec-v1.0-csd01.html).

Two examples:

[CAP-1.2]
Common Alerting Protocol Version 1.2. 01 July 2010. OASIS Standard. http://docs.oasis-open.org/emergency/cap/v1.2/CAP-v1.2-os.html.

[OpenDocument-1.2]
Open Document Format for Office Applications (OpenDocument) Version 1.2. 19 January 2011. OASIS Committee Specification Draft 07. http://docs.oasis-open.org/office/v1.2/csd07/OpenDocument-v1.2-csd07.html.

57-We don't have any control over the html version of the spec. That is done by TC Admin, so we'll have to decline this and see if there are any broken links when the public review draft is produced for us.

58-I don't know what this is referring to. I vote to decline.

59-Correct ttp to http at what was line 1267

60-Check to be sure this reference isn't one of those to be deleted before correcting this link--this may require some time chasing down the correct link--but I bet it is one of those to be deleted.

61-Check to make sure this is not one of the references to be deleted and if not, Use the correct citation per the issue.

62-https://issues.oasis-open.org/browse/EMERGENCY-62 This wasn't included in Robert's list, but we don't generate the pdf,  TC Admin does, so we have to decline.

63-We don't generate line numbers, TC Admin does that, so we should double check with TC Admin tto make sure that is done for the public review.

 

 

On 8/2/2017 12:31 PM, O'Connor, Robert wrote:

Hi, folks. There are 23 open issues in JIRA for HAVE. Most were created over two years ago - none have been updated since 2015.

Any ideas about where to start? Here they are, ordered by most recent Updated Date.

 

Issue Type	Key	Summary	Assignee	Reporter	Priority	Status	Resolution	Created	Updated	Due Date
Bug	EMERGENCY-63	Line Numbering in Document	Unassigned	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	11/10/2015 21:43	11/10/2015 21:43
Bug	EMERGENCY-48	Data Dictionary - Normative Content?	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:14	11/10/2015 21:31
Bug	EMERGENCY-46	Note in 5 Conformance	Unassigned	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:10	11/10/2015 21:21
Bug	EMERGENCY-44	Requirements in Section 4 are unclear	Unassigned	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:06	11/10/2015 21:19
Bug	EMERGENCY-42	References should be non-normative?	Unassigned	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:02	11/10/2015 21:16
Bug	EMERGENCY-41	None of the RFC keywords appear to be used	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:00	11/10/2015 21:11
Bug	EMERGENCY-45	Stability of schema is unclear	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	Closed	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:08	11/3/2015 21:11
Bug	EMERGENCY-43	Bad reference for EDXL-DE	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	Closed	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:04	11/3/2015 21:09
Bug	EMERGENCY-61	Incorrect Reference	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:30	11/3/2015 21:06
Improvement	EMERGENCY-40	The specification does not seem to target EDXL-HAVE processors, unlike other EDXL specifications	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 15:57	11/3/2015 21:06
Bug	EMERGENCY-50	Unused Non-Normative References (11)	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:16	6/16/2015 20:08
Bug	EMERGENCY-49	Normative text?	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:15	6/16/2015 20:07
Bug	EMERGENCY-47	Conformance clause is vague	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:13	6/16/2015 20:05
Bug	EMERGENCY-56	Style variations in 1.2/1.3	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:23	6/2/2015 20:42
Bug	EMERGENCY-60	Link Redirects (8)	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:28	6/2/2015 20:42
Bug	EMERGENCY-59	Broken link (1)	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:27	6/2/2015 20:38
Bug	EMERGENCY-58	Hanging Paragraphs	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:26	6/2/2015 20:38
Bug	EMERGENCY-57	Styling of entries in references	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:25	6/2/2015 20:37
Bug	EMERGENCY-55	Incorrect citation	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Minor	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:22	6/2/2015 20:36
Bug	EMERGENCY-52	Superseded reference	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:18	6/2/2015 20:34
Bug	EMERGENCY-54	Incorrect citation	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:21	6/2/2015 20:34
Bug	EMERGENCY-53	incorrect citation	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:20	6/2/2015 20:34
Bug	EMERGENCY-51	Unused Normative References	Darrell O'Donnell	Darrell O'Donnell	Major	New	Unresolved	6/2/2015 16:18	6/2/2015 20:33

 

 

Disclaimer

This e-mail and its attachments may contain privileged or confidential information. Please consult IEM before sharing this e-mail with anyone else. If you are not the intended recipient of this e-mail, you may not use, copy, distribute, or forward this e-mail. If you received this e-mail by mistake, please notify IEM and immediately delete this message. Although IEM does not know of any viruses present in this e-mail, you are encouraged to scan it using antivirus software, and IEM will not accept responsibility for any loss or damage arising from this e-mail. This e-mail neither constitutes an agreement to conduct transactions by electronic means nor creates any legally binding contract or enforceable obligation in the absence of a fully signed written contract. IEM takes no responsibility for any unauthorized reliance on the contents of this e-mail.

-- 

Rex Brooks

Starbourne Communications Design

Email: rexb@starbourne.com

GeoAddress:

1361 Addison St. Apt. A

Berkeley, CA 94702

Phone: 510-898-0670 

 

Virus-free. www.avast.com

 

Attachment: Draft EDXL-HAVE SC MeetingNotes 2017-08-03.docx
Description: application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document