Public review comments for etmf-v1.0-csprd01: Appendix A. Acknowledgments

["Eldin Rammell, Rammell Consulting" <eldin.rammell@rammell.com>]

Comment type [editorial]

Impact [minor]

Given that this is the first public review of the draft specification, it is not understood why individuals and organizations who are not members of the OASIS eTMF Technical Committee are being acknowledged for their input. Were non-TC members asked to contribute to the draft specification? If so, why was the TMF Reference Model community not asked similarly to contribute formally to the TC as a non-OASIS member? It appears that Kerstin Forsberg (not a member of the TC, I understand) was asked to review the specification prior to opening of the public review period. Why was such an offer not made to the TMF Reference Model community?

 

The acknowledgement of the TMF Reference Model community is notable by its absence.

 

This comment is not intended to be critical of those who have provided external input. It is simply to question the process.

 

Eldin Rammell,

Principal Consultant, Rammell Consulting Ltd.