Re: [id-cloud] 10/31/2011 Oasis ID-Cloud meeting minutes

[Anil Saldhana <Anil.Saldhana@redhat.com>]

Agenda:

1) Roll Call, Agenda Review and Minute Taker Nomination.

Roll Call:
IBM     David Kern     Voting Member
Microsoft     Anthony Nadalin     Chair
Bank of America     Dominique Nguyen     Voting Member
CA Technologies     Christopher Ramstrom     Member
Red Hat     Anil Saldhana     Chair
Rackspace Hosting, Inc.     Joe Savak     Voting Member
Daon     Cathy Tilton     Voting Member
Microsoft     David Turner     Voting Member
New Zealand Government     Colin Wallis     Member

Quorum: 7 out of 13 achieved.

2) Approval of Oct 17th Meeting Minutes (TBD)
Minutes missing. Deferred.

3) Use Case Document - second draft uploaded by Matt.

http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/document.php?document_id=44074&wg_abbrev=id-cloud

4) Gap Analysis Discussion

5) Other Business

6) Adjourn

On 10/31/2011 05:56 PM, Anthony Nadalin wrote:

So around the configuration management question today, I forgot about the NIST effort http://scap.nist.gov/specifications/xccdf/

 

From: id-cloud@lists.oasis-open.org [mailto:id-cloud@lists.oasis-open.org] On Behalf Of Gershon Janssen
Sent: Monday, October 31, 2011 12:09 PM
To: id-cloud@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: RE: [id-cloud] 10/31/2011 Oasis ID-Cloud meeting minutes

 

Hi,

 

Missed the call; DST change confusion! Apologies.

 

Regards,

 

Gershon Janssen

 

 

From: id-cloud@lists.oasis-open.org [mailto:id-cloud@lists.oasis-open.org] On Behalf Of Joe Savak
Sent: maandag 31 oktober 2011 19:34
To: id-cloud@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: [id-cloud] 10/31/2011 Oasis ID-Cloud meeting minutes

 

Thank you for your participation today. Below are the meeting minutes.

 

 

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Good afternoon Joe, Tony

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Hi Anil!

Anthony Nadalin: morning

anonymous morphed into Cathy Tilton

anonymous morphed into David Kern (IBM)

Anthony Nadalin: don't forget to activate phone

David Kern (IBM): Good afternoon, everybody

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): you all should be able to go to oasis site and register ur attendance.

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): go to today;s meeting and register ur attendance

JoeSavak (Rackspace): << Meeting minute taker

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Topic: Approval of Oct 17th Meeting Minutes

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/document.php?document_id=44074&wg_abbrev=id-cloud

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): can u not hear me?

David Turner: nope

JoeSavak (Rackspace): 2nd version draft of id-cloud-usecases

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Matt & Anil working with individual use case submitters and will have a newer version soon

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): http://tools.oasis-open.org/issues/browse/IDCLOUD

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): JIRA project for IDCLoud.

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Topic: Gap analysis discussion

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Template for gap analysis document discussed.

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Wiki version created and feedback requested.

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): http://wiki.oasis-open.org/id-cloud/GapAnalysis

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Topic: Use case 1 gap analysis

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Found virtual machine definition gap

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Editors are Gershon, Roger and Matt

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Topic: Template (gap analysis)

JoeSavak (Rackspace): May be able to use existing gap analysis template (from cloud study workgroup?)

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Action Item for Colin:  give us the ITU-T template for gap analysus

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): analysis

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Topic: Auditing standards

JoeSavak (Rackspace): No clear cut auditing standard in cloud in general

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Something we can incorporate in gap analysis doc

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Gap Analysis discussion about usecases that included audit

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): we found that there are audit standards in general and a couple in cloud : 1 at dmtf and the other in google group (for CSA)

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): so we can incorporate into the gap analysis document that there is a clear need for a cloud auditing standard.

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Use Case doc: http://docs.oasis-open.org/id-cloud/IDCloud-usecases/v1.0/cnd01/IDCloud-usecases-v1.0-cnd01.html

Dominique Nguyen1: Hi- I just joined

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Topic: Use case 4 review

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): any objections?

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Use case is about Standard configuration template for identities for cloud subsystem (one configuration)

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): SCIM (simple cloud identity management)

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): api to CRUD users across cloud services (can be heterogeneous)

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Use case 4 may be solved by SCIM

JoeSavak (Rackspace): SCIM may be a relevant "standard"

JoeSavak (Rackspace): If SCIM doesn't do this, it may expand to do this

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Dominique: Perhaps in template, it would be helpful to show relevant standards?

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Wiki page for gap analysis: http://wiki.oasis-open.org/id-cloud/GapAnalysis

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Gap analysis has relevant standards area

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Definition of configuration is unclear

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Configuration: Common template or format to define infrastructure that can be portable from one IaaS provider to another IaaS

JoeSavak (Rackspace): as an example

JoeSavak (Rackspace): as an example

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Iaas was an example. 

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Topic: Other Business (separate from Halloween)

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Cloud Expo passes in Santa Clara. Free access if interested

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): details are in the email..

JoeSavak (Rackspace): Adjourn

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): dominique: would u like to be gap analysis editor?

AnilSaldhana(RedHat): Joe: copy/paste this text into an email and send to list, plz

JoeSavak (Rackspace): will do!