Dear Monica,
A very first reaction to your document.
Initially, the naming convention in akoma ntoso use the
http "#" to introduce the local information after the
IRI (portion information).
But
the # has a special usage, it is a request for a part,
client side, so the information after the "#" is
never sent to the server. This is a problem and the
solution we found in end of 2014 was to replace the
"#" with the "~", without any other change.
So, for example, the reference
/akn/sl/act/2004-02-13/2/eng@2004-07-21#chp_3 has an
equivalent syntax
/akn/sl/act/2004-02-13/2/eng@2004-07-21~chp_3 where
everything, including the local information are sent to
the server
This usage can also be done on the iri relative to a
work :
/akn/sl/act/2004-02-13/2#chp_3
/akn/sl/act/2004-02-13/2~chp_3
or to an _expression_...
of course, you can refer a local position to the current
document with "#chp_3" and with the alternative syntax,
"~chp_3".
This syntax is used intensively at the EP, the
Commission and starts to be used at the OP (Publication
Office).
Now, if you consider that the ~ is a beautiful character
that you want to use for another usage, please, replace
it with another character for isolate the local part
(for example "$" as you use it when the local info is
alone) so that we have
/akn/sl/act/2004-02-13/2$chp_3
/akn/sl/act/2004-02-13/2/eng@2004-07-21$chp_3
or
$chp_3
The important requirement is that the syntax remains
unique,
with the same structure as the one with the "#"
and allows to separate quickly the local information
from the rest of the iri.
For the rest of the document, I will examine it in the
next days and provide some concret examples from the
european institutions to be sure of my understanding.
Kind regards
Véronique
Dear
LegalDocML,
please find the last version of the
akn-nc-v1.0-wd20.
The next meeting (Nov. 11, 2015) it is
important to have the quorum for approving
this document.
After this approval we can update also the D1.
Yours,
Monica
------------------------
Modifications:
1. COMPONENT AND FRAGMENT
/akn/it/decreto/ministero-salute/2012-04-18/s2124076/~allegato_1/allegato_d
~allegato_1/art_1
use
[Work][@_expression_][!Manifestation-optional-parts]~[Component]/[Fragment].[Format]
2. SUB-JURISDICTION
/akn/it-45/act/ordinanza/regione-er/2012-06-08/1/~allegato/art_1
3. DIVISION OF MANIFESTATION using !
/akn/sl/act/2004-02-13/2/eng@2004-07-21/official/2004-07-25!fabio/2015-10-25.xml
4. Incremental syntax query
decree-ministeral
/akn/it/act/decree-ministerial
/akn/it/act/decree
5. Local reference
~$/art_1
--
===================================
Associate professor of Legal Informatics
School of Law
Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna
C.I.R.S.F.I.D. http://www.cirsfid.unibo.it/
Palazzo Dal Monte Gaudenzi - Via Galliera, 3
I - 40121 BOLOGNA (ITALY)
Tel +39 051 277217
Fax +39 051 260782
E-mail monica.palmirani@unibo.it
====================================