RE: [office] Review of ODF 1.4 Part 3 WD02

["Francis Cave" <francis@franciscave.com>]

Hi Regina

Office-4106: I've added text to the Resolution field in JIRA. I agree that the change in the schema has been made in the wrong instance of style:repeat: lines 9744-9745, but should be between lines 10930 and 10931.

Office-4118: I think that the Resolution field should be completed only after the question about the default value has been resolved, although my view is that the default value should always be specified in the section that describes the attribute, not the parent element, so 19.876.4 and 19.876.7 are the correct sections in which to specify the default values, not in 16.34 (<text:list-level-style-number>) or 16.37 (<text:outline-level-style>).

Office-3022: I've added text to the Resolution field in JIRA. I agree that the schema change has not been made.

Office-4023: I wonder whether it would make sense to move <presentation:sound> to 10.9 SMIL Presentation Animations, in which case the whole of 10.8 can be marked as deprecated. According to the proposal in the JIRA issue, the only reason for not deprecating <presentation:sound> appears to be because of its use in SMIL animations. Perhaps this should be discussed before adding anything to the Resolution field.

Kind regards,

Francis



-----Original Message-----
From: office@lists.oasis-open.org <office@lists.oasis-open.org> On Behalf Of Regina Henschel
Sent: 10 May 2022 18:41
To: Francis Cave <francis@franciscave.com>
Cc: 'ODF TC List' <office@lists.oasis-open.org>; 'Patrick Durusau' <patrick@durusau.net>
Subject: Re: [office] Review of ODF 1.4 Part 3 WD02

Hi Francis,

find my results below.

Kind regards,
Regina

Francis Cave schrieb am 09.05.2022 um 18:48:
> Hi Svante, hi Regina
> 
> Thank you both for your latest reviews. Regina, I have taken the 
> liberty of assigning another batch to you (batch 11), as well as one 
> to Svante (batch 10). See attached spreadsheet.
> 

OASIS-4106
==========
Resolution in issue: Field is empty.
Appendix G: OK
Changes in text: OK
Schema: change is in wrong place. It should be in <rng:define name="style-graphic-fill-properties-attlist"> line 10931.

In case we want the new value for style:repeat of an <style:background-image> (17.3) too, we should reopen the issue. The current resolution is for style:repeat in elements <style:draw-page-properties> (17.25) and <style:graphic-properties> (17.21).

OASIS-4118
==========
Resolution in issue: Field is empty. Here the field must be filled because the comments end with a question.
Appendix G: OK
Changes in text: Not applicable, change is in generated content.
Schema: OK

OASIS-3022
==========
Resolution in issue: Field is empty.
Appendix G: OK
Changes in text: Not applicable, change is in generated content.
Schema: Change is totally missing, should be inside <rng:element name="draw:page">, line 5596

OASIS-4023
==========
Resolution in issue: OK
Appendix G: OK
Changes in text: The remark "(deprecated)" at the heading "10.8 Presentation Animations" is misleading because we still have <presentation:sound> in that section. But that will be the only sub-section after the others are removed. When they are actually removed, we should consider to make <presentation:sound> an independent section and indeed remove "10.8 Presention Animations".
The "(deprecated)" remark is missing on 10.8.3 <presentation:show-shape>. All other changes are OK.
Schema: Not applicable, changes are only needed in text.




---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that generates this mail.  Follow this link to all your TCs in OASIS at:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php