[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Informatics and quantity calculus
Dear QUOMOS TC I commend your attempt to produce a definitive Quantities
and Units Ontology; it is a really important step to making metrological
concepts understandable by software systems. The concepts of
‘quantity’ and ’unit’ seem trivial, but there are other
Q&U ontologies (e.g. SysML-QUDV , UOM , UnitDim, sciUnits ), and they all have trouble
codifying metrological concepts (primarily ‘quantity’,
‘kind-of-quantity’, and ‘dimension’) and with choosing
a set of base quantities (e.g. [amount] and [luminous intensity] are
unnecessary; [angle] and [entity] are desirable). I suggest this is
because there are unresolved conceptual issues in the main metrology documents
the SI, VIM and ISQ. I have reviewed these metrology-related informatics
issues in a recent paper. It may help you avoid some frustration. Foster MP.2010.The next 50 years of the SI: a review of
the opportunities for the e-Science age. Metrologia 47 R41-R51. The International System of Units (SI) was
declared as a practical and evolving system in 1960 and is now 50 years old. A
large amount of theoretical and experimental work has been conducted to change
the standards for the base units from artefacts to physical constants, to
improve their stability and reproducibility. Less attention, however, has been
paid to improving the SI definitions, utility and usability, which suffer from
contradictions, ambiguities and inconsistencies. While humans can often resolve
these issues contextually, computers cannot. As an ever-increasing volume and
proportion of data about physical quantities is collected, exchanged, processed
and rendered by computers, this paper argues that the SI definitions, symbols
and syntax should be made more rigorous, so they can be represented wholly and
unambiguously in ontologies, programs, data and text, and so the SI notation
can be rendered faithfully in print and on screen. Online at stacks.iop.org/Met/47/R41 Marcus Foster PLEASE
NOTE Please consider the environment before printing this email. |
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]