RE: [regrep] Comments regarding UN/CEFACT Registry WD (0.5)

["BEDINI Ivan RD-BIZZ-CAE" <ivan.bedini@francetelecom.com>]

Thank you very mutch Richard for the good comments. 

Next week I will be able to give you all details about the ICG RR mailing list and teleconferences.


Best regards,
Ivan

-----Message d'origine-----
De : Richard Martell [mailto:rmartell@galdosinc.com] 
Envoyé : jeudi 31 mars 2005 20:47
À : regrep@lists.oasis-open.org
Objet : [regrep] Comments regarding UN/CEFACT Registry WD (0.5)

Hi all,


Some comments regarding the latest working draft follow.

* since the UN/CEFACT document is based on ebRS and extends it (workflow
   management, new content types, custom APIs, etc.), a more appropriate
   title might be something like this:

   "The UN/CEFACT profile of the OASIS ebXML Registry Service"

[IB] IMO the UN/CEFACT Registry specifications aren't only a profile of the ebXML Registry, but they define UN/CEFACT needs for manage its artifacts and where possible they use ebXML Registry services.

* line 196: Change "feeding procedure" to "Submission procedure"
   (also title of section 5.2)

[IB] I will report your suggest.

* the conformance clause (2.4) is pretty weak--it should consolidate
   all conformance requirements in the document: e.g.,
     - line 400 regarding federations;
     - line 811 regarding ebRIM mappings;
     - line 844 regarding packaging;
     - constraints listed in 6.4.1;
     - mandatory capabilities from 10.2

[IB] I agree with you. They will be developed

* will conformance testing be required in the future to verify the
   behavior of UN/CEFACT registry services? If so, then the inclusion
   of an abstract test suite may be warranted

[IB] Good point, but this issue isn't considered yet.

* in 6.1.5.2, perhaps substitute "Classification schemes" or
   "Dictionaries" for "Directories", since these items are all kinds of
   code lists and controlled vocabularies. Are these mapped to
   ebRIM classification schemes in some manner? (line 965 doesn't
   address this)

[IB] I think that Filepath Based URL could be used for that (...as Farrukh has already suggested me)

-- 
Richard Martell         Public PGP key: <http://www.galdosinc.com/pgp/>
Galdos Systems, Inc.      tel: +1 604-484-2765  |  fax: +1 604-484-2755

Opinions, conclusions, recommendations, and other information presented in this message are not given or necessarily endorsed by my employer or firm. If the digital signature is invalid, I did not send this message.


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that generates this mail.  You may a link to this group and all your TCs in OASIS
at:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php