Minutes
Scribe: Danny van der Rijn
Agenda bashing
Add to agenda - Higher bar for new issues - under AOB
Agenda approved with one addition
Approval of July 10 minutes
Resolution: July 10 minutes located at http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/sca-bpel/200807/msg00020.html approved unanimously
Action Item followup
AI #21 Still working with Mary to get CD01 posted. Working through details
AI #0042
Michael Rowley:
Put down the pen, who picks it up?
AI #0043
AI #0044
Dieter has completed the AI with a new upload before Michael Rowley's last upload
Schedule of next calls
<Mike Edwards>
I'm currently available for all dates in August
<Mike Edwards>
time to give ourselves a vacation
Danny:
Moves that the TC takes August off. Dieter seconds
Resolution: All August calls are cancelled (motion passes unanimously)
Action: chairs to cancel all august calls
Leaves of absence
Anish:
See forwarded email about leaves of absence - must inform chairs 7 days in advance, etc.
Status of Spec
<Michael Rowley>
Editing work item list is here:
Dieter:
Revision #9 - Michael Rowley mentioned in mail that some of his 2.1 editing got lost, reinserted.
Anish:
TC has not approved yet, so resolution should be folded in without RFC 2119 language
Michael Rowley:
Revision 9 includes proposal for what 2119 language would look like in section 2.1. Could remove, or could approve.
Martin is to fold in two and twenty issues
Issue 18
<Mike Edwards>
Here is an aexample from Policy TC:
<Mike Edwards>
sca-policy-1.1-spec-wd-06_Issue52_Proposal.doc
[Discussion of process of creating documents]
<Mike Edwards>
in Rev 9, which lines do we look at?
<Mike Edwards>
I dont know which lines to lok at...
small typo (repeated a few times) "If a partnerLink specifies has..." (pick either 'specifies' or 'has')
<Mike Edwards>
I agree Danny - that occurs more than once
Michael Rowley:
Strike the word 'has'
<Mike Edwards>
I can't see "Rev5" in the document web page
<Mike Edwards>
I can see "Rev9"
<Mike Edwards>
It might be easier to state that what is described is the introspected componentType
<Mike Edwards>
leaving out the question of how it is actually created
<Mike Edwards>
componenttype is virtual but it is also testable
<Mike Edwards>
this is equally true for the introspected component type of any implementation type - including Java
Michael Rowley moves that Revision 9, section 2.1 be accepted as the resolution of issue 18 for all of section 2.1
<Mike Edwards>
I object as I have not had an opportunity to read it all and I can see several errors already
Someone is typing too close to their microphone
Martin:
in other places, we iron out wordsmithing details before we make motions
Anish:
Motion is allowed. We've had a lot of time to review. Michael made motion to focus issues. Running out of time, so it
may be a moot point
Mike Edwards:
would vote against - text is not ready
Michael Rowley:
Beyond the extra 'has', what other errors?
Mike Edwards:
Wrong namespace for attributes
Anish:
I think the namespace is correct
<Mike Edwards>
I think my line just dropped - sorry
<Mike Edwards>
do we have time for me to redial?
No, Mike, we're finishing
<Mike Edwards>
ok, sorry about that
<Mike Edwards>
I will read the whole section and put comments to the list
Anish:
Between now and next call, look at revision 5 (will send email to point) and urge everyone to send in comments before call,
so we can have a focused discussion next week. Hoping to get resolved next week.
<Mike Edwards>
Rev5 and NOT Rev9, right?
Correct, Mike. Rev 5. Anish will send mail.
Schreiber diagnostics output
[Delete this section before publishing the minutes]
statistics: Schreiber found 88 input lines
edits: Schreiber found the following text-edit commands:
edits: Line 44: Danny van der Rijn: s/uploda/upload/
command-scribe: Line 1: Danny van der Rijn recognized
command-scribe: Schreiber detected that this section was scribed online
edit-substitute: command on line 44 succeeded, changed line 42 from 'uploda' to 'upload'
edit-delete: Line 44 was deleted
system: Transformer: SAXON 9.0.0.2
[End of Schreiber diagnostic output]