RE: [sca-bpel] Proposal for SCA-BPEL Issue 39

["Patil, Sanjay" <sanjay.patil@sap.com>]

Hi Dieter,

I think this issue (#39) as well as an earlier (resolved) issue (#31)[1] impact the same statement in the specification. Therefore I think the resolution for issue 39 should be inclusive of the previously adopted resolution for issue 31.

If I understand the issue 39 correctly, it can be resolving by updating the resolution of the issue 31 as follows.

Change the issue 31 resolution
From
[SBPEL3011] The partnerLinkType and partnerRole attributes of the <partnerLink> MUST be the same as the partnerLinkType and partnerRole attributes of the <sca-bpel:multiReference> child element of the variable whose @name value is same as the value of the @multiRefFrom attribute of the <partnerLink>.

To
[SBPEL3011] The partnerLinkType attribute and the partnerRole of the <partnerLink> MUST be the same as the partnerLinkType and partnerRole attributes of the <sca-bpel:multiReference> child element of the variable whose @name value is same as the value of the @multiRefFrom attribute of the <partnerLink>.

Comments?

-- Sanjay

[1] http://www.osoa.org/jira/browse/BPEL-31


> -----Original Message-----
> From: Dieter Koenig1 [mailto:dieterkoenig@de.ibm.com] 
> Sent: Friday, May 01, 2009 3:28 AM
> To: sca-bpel@lists.oasis-open.org
> Subject: [sca-bpel] Proposal for SCA-BPEL Issue 39
> 
> 
> 
> We discussed the proposal for SCA-BPEL issue 39 (
> http://www.osoa.org/jira/browse/BPEL-39) during the last TC call.
> 
> After re-checking, I think that the current proposal does not 
> need to be
> revised.
> 
> The proposed new text ...
> 
> [SBPEL3011] The partnerLinkType attribute of the partner link and
> multi-valued reference variable MUST be matched and the partnerRole
> attribute of the multi-valued reference variable MUST match 
> the partnerRole
> of the partner link.
> 
> ... only refers to the **partnerRole attribute** of the **multi-valued
> reference** (which always has the partnerRole attribute) and 
> refers to the
> **partnerRole** of the **partner link** (which may only have 
> the myRole
> attribute specified).
> 
> With that, this rule is consistent with others in referring to the
> partnerRole without explicitly requiring the **partnerRole 
> attribute** to
> be present on a **partner link**.
> 
> Let's revisit this in the next call.
> 
> Kind Regards
> 
> Dieter König
> 
> Senior Technical Staff Member, WebSphere Process Server Architect
> IBM Software Group, Application and Integration Middleware Software
> WSS Business Process Solutions
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>   Phone:            +49-7031-16-3426           IBM 
> Deutschland                      (Embedded 
>                                                               
>                     image moved 
>                                                               
>                        to file: 
>                                                               
>                   pic26786.gif) 
>                                                               
>                                 
>   E-Mail:           dieterkoenig@de.ibm.com    Schönaicher 
> Str. 220                           
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                71032 
> Böblingen                                
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                Germany        
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>   IBM Deutschland                                             
>                                 
>   Research &                                                  
>                                 
>   Development                                                 
>                                 
>   GmbH /                                                      
>                                 
>   Vorsitzender des                                            
>                                 
>   Aufsichtsrats:                                              
>                                 
>   Martin Jetter                                               
>                                 
>   Geschäftsführung:                                           
>                                 
>   Erich Baier                                                 
>                                 
>   Sitz der                                                    
>                                 
>   Gesellschaft:                                               
>                                 
>   Böblingen /                                                 
>                                 
>   Registergericht:                                            
>                                 
>   Amtsgericht                                                 
>                                 
>   Stuttgart, HRB                                              
>                                 
>   243294                                                      
>                                 
>                                                               
>                                 
>