Irving's votes on the ballot

[Irving Reid <Irving.Reid@baltimore.com>]

{AP-1} Generalized or specialized solution 

1. We should develop a generalized solution as an interim step to satisfying
the specific requirements identified by the Use Cases sub-committee.


{AP-2} Questions the PEP can ask the PDP 
1.      "Yes/No/Can't decide". 
3.      Specific attributes requested by the PEP. 

As Prateek pointed out, there is almost always useful data to go with a
"yes/no/can't decide" answer.



{AP-3}  Question: should we define a PDP-PDP protocol? 
2.      No.


{AP-4}  The number of assertions in a message 
3.      An unlimited number. 


{AP-5} Combining components 
1.      The model should explicitly identify that components of the model
may be combined. 

The model should _not_ describe which specific combinations are required,
allowed, or prohibited.

{AP-6} Assertion validation component 
Abstain.

As I see it, assertion validation is implicit in the concept of the 'relying
party'; if the RP can't tell if the assertion is valid, it shouldn't rely.
I'm happy to let the rest of you decide whether to call it out.


 - irving -