security-use message

Subject: Tim's vote RE: (REALLY) FINAL BALLOTS, GROUPS 6, 7, 8, 9

Title: Tim's vote RE: (REALLY) FINAL BALLOTS, GROUPS 6, 7, 8, 9

Group 6: Protocol Bindings

ISSUE:[UC-6-01:XMLProtocol]

2. Leave current binding to SOAP.

Group 7: Enveloping Versus Enveloped

ISSUE:[UC-7-01:Enveloping]

1. Add this proposed requirement.

ISSUE:[UC-7-02:Enveloped]

1. Add this proposed requirement.

Group 8: Intermediaries

ISSUE:[UC-8-01:Intermediaries]

1. Add this requirement to the document.

ISSUE:[UC-8-02:IntermediaryAdd]

2. Don't add this use-case scenario.

ISSUE:[UC-8-03:IntermediaryDelete]

2. Don't add this use-case scenario.

ISSUE:[UC-8-04:IntermediaryEdit]

2. Don't add this use-case scenario.

ISSUE:[UC-8-05:AtomicAssertion]

1. Add this non-goal to the document, and change use case scenarios
to specify that intermediaries must treat assertions as atomic.

Group 9: Privacy

ISSUE:[UC-9-01:RuntimePrivacy]

1. Add this proposed non-goal.
2. Do not add this proposed non-goal.

ISSUE:[UC-9-02:PrivacyStatement]

3. Add [CR-9-02-4-DisclosureMishra] as a requirement.