[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: FW: attachment of DoDAF name and one-liner cleanups relevant totomorrow's WG
Colleagues. And the beat
goes on, and on, and on… (attachment included). Cheers…
- J From: Lichtblau, Dale E
[mailto:del@ida.org] All: I've made it through page 3 of the attachment referenced
in the original email. Should the heading of page 3 read "SERVICES AND
DODAF V2.0—OVERLOADING THE TERM ‘SERVICE’”? (I
don’t know how you overload a service, as a term or as anything...but I
quibble. The official DODAF V2.0 definition begins “Service:
A mechanism to enable access to a set of one or more capabilities....
The mechanism is a Performer” [emphasis added]. The Jedi Knights say that “DM2 defines Service as a
subtype of Performer. Via the definition above, one can see a Service is not a
Performer.” Huh? If a service is a mechanism and a mechanism is a performer,
it follows by the transitivity of “is a” that a service is a
performer.” Am I missing something? Should I bother reading further? I’m not agreeing with the DODAF definition of the
term “service.” It’s being used as technical term and, as
such, can be defined anyway the authors want it to be defined, as long as
it’s coherent and consistent with the other technical terms used in the
definition. I believe the metamodel for DODAF 2.0 says that “services are
activities done by a...provider to achieve desired results for
a...consumer.” A service can also be that which “executes an
activity and provides a capability.” All of these terms (“activity,”
“performer,” “capability,” “mechanism,”
“means,” “consumer,” “results,”
“intrinsic value,” “result of,” “provide,”
“produce,” “invoke,” “desired,”
“resource,” etc.) must be rigorously defined and those definitions
need to be collectively consistent and coherent. (Note that something—a
service—might be of value even though it has no intrinsic value
(or its intrinsic value is not the value one is deriving a benefit from). I use
old computer monitors for doorstops. Do they have intrinsic doorstop
value?) Thanks, Dale -----Original Message----- I certainly agree with Lawrence. This needed to be
said. -----Original Message----- From: McCaskill, Lawrence [mailto:lmccaskill@WBBINC.COM] Sent: Thursday, October 21, 2010 6:39 PM To: Dave McDaniel; Ho, Lily; Oestreich, Paul; McAdoo,
Daniel; Tanner, Craig ; Walkup, Roger; Snyder, Forrest ; Haberkamp, Bruce ;
Dandashi, Fatma ; Phelps, Christopher; Dandashi, Fatma ; Snyder, Forrest ;
Patel, Alka B.; Tanner, Craig; Yokley, Charles A.; Gonzales, James;
Lichtblau, Dale E; Pettway, Lisa; Houston, Michael; vanDunk, Dawnetta ;
Perper, Allen; Perper, Allen; White, Ken; Brown, Esther ; Brown, Esther ; Muth,
Liesel; Hinchey, Michael; Francis, Andre; Francis, Andre; Tanner, Craig;
Nguyen, Bao; Holt, Vivienne; Jiang; Coleman, Randy; Mow, Ivan ; Schaefer,
Gregory ; Zapata, Edward; Dryer, David A; zurMuehlen, Micheal; Khem, Mike;
Damashek, Robert; Coleman, Lori; Billings, Juanita; Worthy, Victoria;
Minekime, Norm; Mazyck, Alphonso F; Coffin, Jeffrey; Roche, Pat ; Stewart, Mike ;
Ian Bailey; Schaefer, Gregory ; Kihlstrom, Lars-Olof; Chris
Partridge; Steve McCarthy; Stephen McCarthy; Worthy, Victoria; Durham, James ;
Durham, M; Boyles, Stephanie; Robert Stenerson; Dunn, Thomas; Lewis, Robert
; Palasek, Ralph ; Thornburg, Charles; Cox, Brad; Terebesi, Paul; Hood,
Debora ; Spafford, Tim ; Rao, Manohar ; Moreland, Clarence; Choi, Jong Sup ;
Yoman, Johnny; Levine, Leonard; Brown, Dustan; Rivett, Pete ; Parrone, Theresa;
UPDMGroup@OMG.org; Kapadia, Rajan ; Dorman, Eric; Ellis, Dave; Hunnicutt,
Tim ; Hunnicutt, Tim; Godfrey-Welch, Darlene; Subbarao,Suma ; Kufro, Scott ;
Taporco, Timothy; Green, Cathy ; Dryer, David ; Insolia, Anthony ;
Komorowski, Ian; Varveris, Lou ; Wilson, Jeffery ; Bellomo, Stephany ; Chambers,
Henry ; Jones, Peter ; Lewandowski, Matt; Torreon, Ben ; Wingo, Fumie; Wojcik,
Rob ; Wolfe, Jim ; Brett, Kevin L; Sabol, Bruce R; Green, David ; Rohatgi,
Mukesh ; Halleckson, Brandi; Degraffenreid, Rick; Degraffenreid, Rick ;
Wilson, Allen; Bean, Theodore T.; Brennan, Keith; Phillips, Arnold; Garnot Ms.
Michael B; Vider - Picker, Kobi ; Lee, Jason E; Temaner, Marco; Wilson,
Scott ; Ko, Higgin; Pineda, Jerome ; Nallon, John ; Jorgensen, John M.;
Psimas, Rob ; Anderson, William ; Morrow, Tim; Casanave, Cory; Parikh, Link ;
Bienvenu, Michael ; Fiebrandt, Mark ; White, Chris; Wayson, Michael;
Benfield, Andrew ; Clay, Chris ; Osborne, Kenneth R.; Bahrs, Paul ; Dilks, Timothy
; Cooney, Shawn; Hal Beumer; Arp, Robert ; Wittel, Martin L.; Sizemore,
Nicky; Cornelsen, Rob ; Cornelsen, Robert ; Cornelsen, Robert ; Kindrick, Jim ;
Choi, Don ; Blondino, Krista ; Buchanan, Ian ; Le, Kristina ; Lee,
Shelton; Ruesche-Jr, Daniel H; Simmons, Shawn D; Young, Kendall; Mauro, Tony ;
Reeves, John ; Ebrahim, Sara; Geyer, Olaf; Thornburg, Charles ; Cornell,
Kevin ; Patton, Brian ; Reynolds, Timothy ; Kalbfleisch, Gail; Aaron, Robert;
Ambekar, Venu; Badger, Scott ; Badger, Scott B; Ian Bailey; Hal Beumer;
Binney, Bruce C.; Bleakley, Graham ; Bocast,Alexander ; Boyd, Jason;
Brooks, Rex; Carlson,Terry; Cromwell, Craig; Damera, Hari; Delcarmen,
Francis ; Durham, M; Estefan, Jeff; Folk, Tom; Gallagher, Richard ;
Garnier, Jean-luc; Goerg, Kenneth; Guning, Linda; Hagle, Terry ; Hawkins, Zachary;
Reynolds, Ted; Jordan, Mary Ann ; Kihlstrom, Lars-Olof; Kulakowski,
Walter; Laskey, Ken; Stephenson, Gary; Le, Thatch; Maldonado, Chriss; Steve McCarthy;
McCauslin, Ann; McClendon, Tom; Meyer, Bryce; Moser, Benjamin;
Olson, James; Chris Partridge; Putman, David; Randolph, Robert; Denker, Grit;
Blancett, Chris; Ford, Reginald ; Smith, Kathy ; Frye, Troy; Darrmenen,
Stig B. ; Rich, Brian; Wilson, Jeff; Wilson, Jeffery W.; Smith, Winona;
Holliday, Jim; Walton, Tony L; Dougherty, Mike; Link, William; O'Dell,
Jack ; Fink, Mark; Herr, Julie; Bocast, Alexander; Bock, Conrad; Thornburg,
Charles; Loya, Reuben; Pierce, Walter; Ruel, Chris; Sandridge, Brian; Caron,
Guy; Carryer, David ; Bates, Yvonne ; Bates, Yvonne ; McQuain, Terry ;
Ison, Bill ; Cleary, Aaron ; Dalpini,Thomas ; Dalpini, Thomas ; Dryer,
David ; Wade, Charles ; Dove, Gordon; Leath, Timothy; Minter, Mary CTR;
Baehre, Mark; Abramson, Michael ; Chan, Kar ; stephen.pierson;
Greenman, Corinne ; LaFontaine, Juanita ; Bilak, John; Unger, Jeffrey ;
Roberts, David ; Cole, Vic ; Dougherty, Mike; Wilson, Jeffery W ; Rodriguez,
Efrain L. ; Rodriguez, Efrain L. ; Alder, George ; Alder, George; Abramson,
Michael ; Braithwaite, Dexter; Braithwaite, Dexter; Brown, Esther ; Choi, Don;
Cole, Vic ; Cornelsen, Rob ; Higley, Richard; Holliday, Jim; Stephen
McCarthy; Moreland, Clarence; Mow, Ivan ; Mow, Ivan ; Olson, James; Wittel,
Martin L.; Wittel, Martin L.; Brown, Bruce Owen; Brown, Bruce Owen; Rotz,
Jamison; Rotz, Jamison; Booth, Stuart; Booth, Stuart; Smillie, Robert;
Hagen, Lance; Hagen, Lance; Theos, George; Theos, George; Pollock, Samantha
(Geiger); Pollock, Samantha (Geiger) ; Wood, John; Wright, Scott;
Satterfield, W. Jacob ; Jordon, Laura; Knapp, Beverly; Stephenson, Gary ; Davis,
Chuck; Gilbertson, Russell; Lindgren, Donald; Parsons, Darrell; Rodgers,
Roy; Davis, Chuck; Hanson, Geoff; Hart, Laura; Sellers, Sharon; Gupton,
Kevin; Lawrence McGovern; Ruggiero, Jerry; McGovern, Lawrence; Ruggiero,
Jerry; Belasco, Alan; McNally, Alice; Levine, Len; Jones, Jeffrey;
Sparks, Lori; Lamartin, David; Johnson, Donald; Lamberth, Rick; Lamberth, Rick;
Stephenson, Michael; Young, David Subject: RE: attachment of DoDAF name and one-liner
cleanups relevant to tomorrow's WG This is good stuff. As an active practitioner, the
only thing that would please me more would be to have the suggestions in the
attached implemented... V/R, Lar Lawrence P. McCaskill Senior Manager / Chief Enterprise Architect WBB
Consulting 11790 Sunrise Valley Drive Reston, VA 20191 703-448-6081 x127 Fax: 703-821-6955 lmccaskill@wbbinc.com www.wbbinc.com <http://www.wbbinc.com> -----Original Message----- From: Dave McDaniel
[mailto:David.McDaniel@SilverBulletInc.com] Sent: Thursday, October 21, 2010 4:22 PM To: Ho, Lily; Oestreich, Paul; McAdoo, Daniel; Tanner,
Craig ; Walkup, Roger; Snyder, Forrest ; Haberkamp, Bruce ; Dandashi,
Fatma ; Phelps, Christopher; Dandashi, Fatma ; Snyder, Forrest ; Patel,
Alka B.; Tanner, Craig; Yokley, Charles A.; Gonzales, James; Lichtblau,
Dale E; Pettway, Lisa; Houston, Michael; vanDunk, Dawnetta ; Perper,
Allen; Perper, Allen; White, Ken; Brown, Esther ; Brown, Esther ; Muth, Liesel;
Hinchey, Michael; Francis, Andre; Francis, Andre; Tanner, Craig; Nguyen,
Bao; Holt, Vivienne; Jiang; Coleman, Randy; Mow, Ivan ; Schaefer, Gregory ;
Zapata, Edward; Dryer, David A; zurMuehlen, Micheal; Khem, Mike;
Damashek, Robert; Coleman, Lori; Billings, Juanita; Worthy, Victoria; Minekime,
Norm; Mazyck, Alphonso F; Coffin, Jeffrey; Roche, Pat ; Stewart, Mike ; Ian
Bailey; Schaefer, Gregory ; Kihlstrom, Lars-Olof; Chris Partridge; Steve
McCarthy; Stephen McCarthy; Worthy, Victoria; Durham, James ; Durham, M;
Boyles, Stephanie; Robert Stenerson; Dunn, Thomas; Lewis, Robert ; Palasek,
Ralph ; Thornburg, Charles; Cox, Brad; Terebesi, Paul; Hood, Debora ;
Spafford, Tim ; Rao, Manohar ; Moreland, Clarence; Choi, Jong Sup ; Yoman,
Johnny; Levine, Leonard; Brown, Dustan; Rivett, Pete ; Parrone, Theresa;
UPDMGroup@OMG.org; Kapadia, Rajan ; Dorman, Eric; Ellis, Dave; Hunnicutt,
Tim ; Hunnicutt, Tim; Godfrey-Welch, Darlene; Subbarao,Suma ; Kufro, Scott ;
Taporco, Timothy; Green, Cathy ; Dryer, David ; Insolia, Anthony ;
McCaskill, Lawrence; Komorowski, Ian; Varveris, Lou ; Wilson, Jeffery ;
Bellomo, Stephany ; Chambers, Henry ; Jones, Peter ; Lewandowski, Matt;
Torreon, Ben ; Wingo, Fumie; Wojcik, Rob ; Wolfe, Jim ; Brett, Kevin L; Sabol,
Bruce R; Green, David ; Rohatgi, Mukesh ; Halleckson, Brandi;
Degraffenreid, Rick; Degraffenreid, Rick ; Wilson, Allen; Bean, Theodore T.;
Brennan, Keith; Phillips, Arnold; Garnot Ms. Michael B; Vider - Picker,
Kobi ; Lee, Jason E; Temaner, Marco; Wilson, Scott ; Ko, Higgin; Pineda,
Jerome ; Nallon, John ; Jorgensen, John M.; Psimas, Rob ; Anderson, William ;
Morrow, Tim; Casanave, Cory; Parikh, Link ; Bienvenu, Michael ; Fiebrandt, Mark
; White, Chris; Wayson, Michael; Benfield, Andrew ; Clay, Chris ;
Osborne, Kenneth R.; Bahrs, Paul ; Dilks, Timothy ; Cooney, Shawn; Hal Beumer;
Arp, Robert ; Wittel, Martin L.; Sizemore, Nicky; Cornelsen, Rob ;
Cornelsen, Robert ; Cornelsen, Robert ; Kindrick, Jim ; Choi, Don ; Blondino,
Krista ; Buchanan, Ian ; Le, Kristina ; Lee, Shelton; Ruesche-Jr, Daniel H;
Simmons, Shawn D; Young, Kendall; Mauro, Tony ; Reeves, John ; Ebrahim,
Sara; Geyer, Olaf; Thornburg, Charles ; Cornell, Kevin ; Patton, Brian ;
Reynolds, Timothy ; Kalbfleisch, Gail; Aaron, Robert; Ambekar, Venu; Badger,
Scott ; Badger, Scott B; Ian Bailey; Hal Beumer; Binney, Bruce C.;
Bleakley, Graham ; Bocast,Alexander ; Boyd, Jason; Brooks, Rex;
Carlson,Terry; Cromwell, Craig; Damera, Hari; Delcarmen, Francis ; Durham, M; Estefan,
Jeff; Folk, Tom; Gallagher, Richard ; Garnier, Jean-luc; Goerg, Kenneth;
Guning, Linda; Hagle, Terry ; Hawkins, Zachary; Reynolds, Ted; Jordan,
Mary Ann ; Kihlstrom, Lars-Olof; Kulakowski, Walter; Laskey, Ken;
Stephenson, Gary; Le, Thatch; Maldonado, Chriss; Steve McCarthy; McCauslin,
Ann; McClendon, Tom; Meyer, Bryce; Moser, Benjamin; Olson, James; Chris
Partridge; Putman, David; Randolph, Robert; Denker, Grit; Blancett, Chris; Ford,
Reginald ; Smith, Kathy ; Frye, Troy; Darrmenen, Stig B. ; Rich, Brian;
Wilson, Jeff; Wilson, Jeffery W.; Smith, Winona; Holliday, Jim; Walton, Tony L;
Dougherty, Mike; Link, William; O'Dell, Jack ; Fink, Mark; Herr, Julie;
Bocast, Alexander; Bock, Conrad; Thornburg, Charles; Loya, Reuben; Pierce,
Walter; Ruel, Chris; Sandridge, Brian; Caron, Guy; Carryer, David ; Bates,
Yvonne ; Bates, Yvonne ; McQuain, Terry ; Ison, Bill ; Cleary, Aaron ;
Dalpini,Thomas ; Dalpini, Thomas ; Dryer, David ; Wade, Charles ; Dove, Gordon;
Leath, Timothy; Minter, Mary CTR; Baehre, Mark; Abramson, Michael ; Chan,
Kar ; stephen.pierson; Greenman, Corinne ; LaFontaine, Juanita
; Bilak, John; Unger, Jeffrey ; Roberts, David ; Cole, Vic ; Dougherty,
Mike; Wilson, Jeffery W ; Rodriguez, Efrain L. ; Rodriguez, Efrain L. ;
Alder, George ; Alder, George; Abramson, Michael ; Braithwaite, Dexter;
Braithwaite, Dexter; Brown, Esther ; Choi, Don; Cole, Vic ; Cornelsen, Rob ;
Higley, Richard; Holliday, Jim; Stephen McCarthy; Moreland, Clarence; Mow,
Ivan ; Mow, Ivan ; Olson, James; Wittel, Martin L.; Wittel, Martin L.;
Brown, Bruce Owen; Brown, Bruce Owen; Rotz, Jamison; Rotz, Jamison; Booth,
Stuart; Booth, Stuart; Smillie, Robert; Hagen, Lance; Hagen, Lance;
Theos, George; Theos, George; Pollock, Samantha (Geiger); Pollock, Samantha
(Geiger) ; Wood, John; Wright, Scott; Satterfield, W. Jacob ; Jordon, Laura;
Knapp, Beverly; Stephenson, Gary ; Davis, Chuck; Gilbertson, Russell;
Lindgren, Donald; Parsons, Darrell; Rodgers, Roy; Davis, Chuck; Hanson,
Geoff; Hart, Laura; Sellers, Sharon; Gupton, Kevin; McGovern, Lawrence ;
Ruggiero, Jerry; McGovern, Lawrence; Ruggiero, Jerry; Belasco, Alan;
McNally, Alice; Levine, Len; Jones, Jeffrey; Sparks, Lori; Lamartin, David;
Johnson, Donald; Lamberth, Rick; Lamberth, Rick; Stephenson, Michael;
Young, David Subject: attachment of DoDAF name and one-liner cleanups
relevant to tomorrow's WG DoDAF-DM2 WG, Attached is the merge of several inputs for the name and
one-liner cleanups relevant to tomorrow's WG. We started this last WG
and I said I'd merge Alex's material in and distribute. Sorry this didn't go out in the readahead package -- Regards/Dave McDaniel Silver Bullet Solutions, Inc. (703) 892-6062 x2# (DC) (619) 237-9220 (San Diego) (619) 253-9040 (mobile) www.silverbulletinc.com |
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]