RE: [topicmapmail] Re: [sc34wg3] Requirements and Recommendations: Part 1 Version 1.0 rev 1 (1.01)

["Bernard Vatant" <bernard.vatant@mondeca.com>]

Hello Tony

Good catch, as usual.

Fragment identifiers have come up again and again on the PubSubj TC table,
without clear consensus on them, except on the fact they are an issue. All
depends how you understand "resolve" (not to mention
"human-interpretable").

Current browsers don't resolve XML fragment identifiers. So in the current
state of the art, you are right. But suppose you add to your browser the
capacity to resolve the XML fragment identifiers, and they become valid
PSIs.

Think about something akin to hyperdaml navigation

http://www.mondeca.com/owl/lang.rdf#fre is not a valid PSI.

But what about that one?
http://www.daml.org/cgi-bin/hyperdaml?http://www.mondeca.com/owl/lang.rdf#f
re

Suppose you somehow manage to redirect the first URL to the second one ...
and the did is done.
I guess this kind of hack can be done for XTM files, and I'm amazed it's
not yet available somewhere.

Don't know if that helps or if it adds to confusion.

Cheers

Bernard


Bernard Vatant
Senior Consultant
Knowledge Engineering
Mondeca - www.mondeca.com
bernard.vatant@mondeca.com

> -----Message d'origine-----
> De : topicmapmail-admin@infoloom.com
> [mailto:topicmapmail-admin@infoloom.com]De la part de Anthony B. Coates
> Envoyé : lundi 21 juillet 2003 23:24
> À : tm-pubsubj-comment@lists.oasis-open.org
> Cc : topicmapmail@infoloom.com
> Objet : [topicmapmail] Re: [sc34wg3] Requirements and Recommendations:
> Part 1 Version 1.0 rev 1 (1.01)
>
>
> ** Reply to message from Mary Nishikawa
> <nisikawa@fuchinobe.oilfield.slb.com>
> on Tue, 15 Jul 2003 14:19:41 +0900
>
> > Description:
> > Ms Word, PDF and zipped HTML  versions of Topic Map Published Subjects
> > Requirements and Recommendations: Part 1
> > OASIS Committee Specification, voted and approved on June 24, 2003
>
> Am I correct in concluding that because "A Published Subject
> Identifier must
> resolve to an human-interpretable Published Subject Indicator",
> URL fragment
> identifiers pointing to topics in an XTM document will not be
> valid PSIs?  So
> "http://psi.fruits.org/#apple" may not point to a topic with ID
> "apple" in an
> XTM document at ""http://psi.fruits.org/", if it is to be a
> valid PSI?  Thanks
> a lot,
>
> 	Cheers,
> 		Tony.
> ====
> Anthony B. Coates, Director
> Information Design, Messaging and Management
> mailto:abcoates@idmm.co.uk
> Mobile/Cell: +44 (79) 0543 9026
> ====
> MDDL Editor (Market Data Definition Language)
> http://www.mddl.org/
> FpML AWG Member (Financial Products Markup Language)
> http://www.fpml.org/
> _______________________________________________
> topicmapmail mailing list
> topicmapmail@infoloom.com
> http://www.infoloom.com/mailman/listinfo/topicmapmail
>