Re: [ubl-comment] Distribution of Naming and Design Rules positionpapers

[Martin Bryan <mtbryan@sgml.u-net.com>]

Eve

Re Arofan's tag spec draft, which includes the sentence in 1.3.3:

The names of intermediate elements MUST contain the Property Term describing
the element and MAY be preceded by an appropriate Qualifier term as
necessary to create semantic clarity at that level. The Object Class MAY be
used as a qualifier.

I would suggest that this should read:

The names of intermediate elements MUST contain the Property Term describing
the element which MUST followed by an  appropriate Qualifier term whenever
the same Property Term is used for more than one element. The Object Class
MAY be used as a qualifier in front of the Property Term.

In 1.3.5 I would suggest that the rule be relaxed so that those elements
whose Representation Typeis a name do not need to have Name appended to
their element names.

Martin Bryan